Saelune said:
I really liked Guardians but even I wont pretend the ending wasnt stupid. Though Quill is half-human, since his mother is human.
Yes, he's half-human, but it's basically an arse-pull. Quill being half...whatever, can basically be used to justify anything within the setting now. Aspyxiation? Gunfire? Poison? I mean, he survived being zapped by the stone because of his biology (and the "power of friendship"...gah!), so what else can he withstand?
Kenbo Slice said:
That fight was awful. Also they should've given Wonder Woman the kryptonite spear, because that's what any intelligent person would do.
I'm not defending the fight, but I can't blame the sequence of events. Bats isn't good for much, Wonder Woman has Doomsday bound, Supes has the spear. Oh sure, you could try to switch weapons, but that's risking a lot in the heat of the moment.
Which is funny, because the final fight in Guardians is even more rediculous. Ronan has a stone that can kill all life on Xandar, so why not smuggle himself in? Why launch a full assault?
hermes said:
and they spoiled the "twist" of two Terminator movies in a row (the, arguably, only inspired parts of those movies).
Both twists? I know John was "spoiled" in Genisys, but what twist in Salvation? Marcus Wright? I think most people could guess the twist long before it was revealed.
I'd also argue that there's a lot to like in both movies, flawed as they are. They're still light-years ahead of Rise of the Machines.
Samtemdo8 said:
I find the movie to be childish,saccharine, and unbelieveably corny and definately not a good representation of what a Superhero movie should be.
I'm not sure if one can really say what a movie "should be." I'm not even sure if Guardians qualifies as a superhero movie - it's more a "space adventure." But yes, I agree with the assessment.
Laughing Man said:
The same movie that starts with the kid having to deal with his Mum dying of cancer. The same movie that has two characters who have lost their entire families to the various bad guys. Not really sure how much better a movie gets by having the characters spend half the screen time mopping around coming to terms with their lose.
Happyninja42 said:
No tragedy or hardships? Starlord's mother dies in front of him, and his last memory of her is refusing to hold her hand (and the guilt that would fester in his heart), before he is abducted by aliens, and basically forced to survive with a group of mercenaries who threatened to eat him every day apparently. According to the guy who raised him, and even if they weren't really going to eat him, using that threat of life on a child would fuck them up seriously. Starlord even comments about that later.
Rocket was a science experiment, repeatedly cut open, limbs severed, and then reattached over and over to perfect his state. He even loses his shit in the movie about how horrific that was for him. Gammora had to serve a person she hated, simply to try and get a chance to kill him, the guy who murdered her family, and, like Starlord, basically press ganged her into serving him against her will. Batista's family was murdered, and he swore his life to avenging them. And when he finally had the chance to get his revenge, he did it by basically betraying his companions, putting all of the galaxy at risk, just for his petty vengeance...a vengeance he didn't even get, because he got his ass kicked by the antagonist. I'm not really seeing how those things are examples of a lack of tragedy and hardships.
I'm not saying that those moments aren't there, but at least for me, they all fall flat.
Peter gets some gravitas with his mother, but the eating thing is played for laughs, including his reaction to it. Rocket does get a breakdown of "I don't even know what I am," but it only comes up when he's drunk, and IIRC, never brought up again. If he's tormented by his experiences, it barely even shows. Then we get other characters, but it's hard to sympathize with them because their problems stem from Ronan, and Ronan is a terrible villain, even by the standards of the MCU.
And I know that people like saying "I don't want a mopey character all film" (nevermind that excellent films have been made on that premise), but if BvS is going to one end of the spectrum with its angst, Guardians is at the other end, and systemic of the MCU's failings as a whole - terrible villains and a lack of gravitas/consequence.