Has WoW met its potential match?

Recommended Videos

Ashsaver

Your friendly Yandere
Jun 10, 2010
1,892
0
0
The only game that can kills WoW is gonna have to be a Blizzard's game.
 

Kagim

New member
Aug 26, 2009
1,200
0
0
Lancer723 said:
New Players wanting to get into WoW need the original game plus...3 expansions now...4? I can't even remember. Plus the monthly fee

New Players wanting to get into Old Republic only need to buy one game....plus the monthly fee. Still it's newer, has a great universe to build on and is markedly easier to get into, plus everyone's on square one with the new game, instead of having tons of people who have already been playing for years.
Actually many people will be starting from square one with the new expansion, since the starting zones are being rebuilt this expansion lots of players will be experiencing a lot of new content for the first time.

Kurokasumi said:
I think with SW:TOR as well as Guild Wars 2 on the way, I don't think WoW will necessarily 'die' but I think it's population will take a massive nose dive
That's what they said about the last six dozen games that were released...
 

Kurokasumi

New member
Aug 11, 2009
141
0
0
Kagim said:
Lancer723 said:
New Players wanting to get into WoW need the original game plus...3 expansions now...4? I can't even remember. Plus the monthly fee

New Players wanting to get into Old Republic only need to buy one game....plus the monthly fee. Still it's newer, has a great universe to build on and is markedly easier to get into, plus everyone's on square one with the new game, instead of having tons of people who have already been playing for years.
Actually many people will be starting from square one with the new expansion, since the starting zones are being rebuilt this expansion lots of players will be experiencing a lot of new content for the first time.

Kurokasumi said:
I think with SW:TOR as well as Guild Wars 2 on the way, I don't think WoW will necessarily 'die' but I think it's population will take a massive nose dive
That's what they said about the last six dozen games that were released...
True, but that's what *they* said. I personally never thought it would happen. This is the first time I actually think WoW might take a dive.
 

Kagim

New member
Aug 26, 2009
1,200
0
0
Kurokasumi said:
Kagim said:
Lancer723 said:
New Players wanting to get into WoW need the original game plus...3 expansions now...4? I can't even remember. Plus the monthly fee

New Players wanting to get into Old Republic only need to buy one game....plus the monthly fee. Still it's newer, has a great universe to build on and is markedly easier to get into, plus everyone's on square one with the new game, instead of having tons of people who have already been playing for years.
Actually many people will be starting from square one with the new expansion, since the starting zones are being rebuilt this expansion lots of players will be experiencing a lot of new content for the first time.

Kurokasumi said:
I think with SW:TOR as well as Guild Wars 2 on the way, I don't think WoW will necessarily 'die' but I think it's population will take a massive nose dive
That's what they said about the last six dozen games that were released...
True, but that's what *they* said. I personally never thought it would happen. This is the first time I actually think WoW might take a dive.
All i am saying is don't hold your breath.

Star wars Galaxies pre-cocking it up(Otherwise known as NGE) was not only star wars, but incredibly unique, fun, and to this day un-emulated in its innovative design of an MMO.

And she got put down. It was nothing like WoW, and she was killed on me. I just don't see anything beating WoW or hurting its population in any permanent way.

Maybe I am bitter. But the way i see this happening is the same thing with Warhammer and Star Trek and LotR. Three Incredibly popular IP's, IP's that were about a thousand times more popular then WoW at its release, that failed to even cough at it threateningly.

That's not to say ToR will not be popular, that's very very likely to happen. Just i don't see millions of people leaving WoW like people are doom saying.
 

viranimus

Thread killer
Nov 20, 2009
4,952
0
0
Kagim said:
4.0 is essentially rebuilding the entire game graphically, and content wise as well, bringing it up to speed with WoTLk which looks fairly good. So instead of treating to crappy computers 5 years ago it will be catering to crappy computers of 2010. Remember a huge selling point of WoW is that older computers can play it on its low settings.

The entire old world is literally being thrown out and replaced with the new one. That's the point of 4.0. To replace the game without replacing the game.
Absolutely and I think its a good thing for WoW, (although 2 out of 3 of the PCs wow has been played on in my house will not be able to handle WoW post cataclysm.) But consider Blizzards turn around time on expansions (which I actually applaud blizzard for) They rebuild the game now, and say this time next year if the conventions TOR adds to the MMO world are starting to stick, do you think Blizzard is going to be inclined to rebuild their world yet again, just to add in something like a cut scene engine or a dialogue matrix? If anything that effort will likely go toward a new MMO project all together.

As for the people who think ToR is just going to be another corpse on the pile in WoWs wake. Sorry, no. Its driven by a company who has a created a niche market, and fueled by two semi linked fanbases, both of which are quite rabid in their own rights. The only thing that will keep ToR from taking over WoWs spot is the fact that it will not appeal to the asian markets the same way WoW has. I see WoW as remaining where they are for a few years to come, but I see ToR overtaking WoW in ENG markets relatively quickly.

And Lets be honest on 2 facts. One blizzard fudges the hell out of their sub numbers. two, WoW Isnt the largest MMO out there.
 

Kurokasumi

New member
Aug 11, 2009
141
0
0
Kagim said:
Kurokasumi said:
Kagim said:
Lancer723 said:
New Players wanting to get into WoW need the original game plus...3 expansions now...4? I can't even remember. Plus the monthly fee

New Players wanting to get into Old Republic only need to buy one game....plus the monthly fee. Still it's newer, has a great universe to build on and is markedly easier to get into, plus everyone's on square one with the new game, instead of having tons of people who have already been playing for years.
Actually many people will be starting from square one with the new expansion, since the starting zones are being rebuilt this expansion lots of players will be experiencing a lot of new content for the first time.

Kurokasumi said:
I think with SW:TOR as well as Guild Wars 2 on the way, I don't think WoW will necessarily 'die' but I think it's population will take a massive nose dive
That's what they said about the last six dozen games that were released...
True, but that's what *they* said. I personally never thought it would happen. This is the first time I actually think WoW might take a dive.
All i am saying is don't hold your breath.

Star wars Galaxies pre-cocking it up(Otherwise known as NGE) was not only star wars, but incredibly unique, fun, and to this day un-emulated in its innovative design of an MMO.

And she got put down. It was nothing like WoW, and she was killed on me. I just don't see anything beating WoW or hurting its population in any permanent way.

Maybe I am bitter. But the way i see this happening is the same thing with Warhammer and Star Trek and LotR. Three Incredibly popular IP's, IP's that were about a thousand times more popular then WoW at its release, that failed to even cough at it threateningly.

That's not to say ToR will not be popular, that's very very likely to happen. Just i don't see millions of people leaving WoW like people are doom saying.
This is what I'm loving about the escapist so far... being able to have conversations with people about things as popular as WoW and not have simple comebacks as 'Lol no f*** u WoW 4evr' I salute you sir.
But on topic, I am not holding my breath in the least, and I could care less if WoW fell or stays right where it is. All I care about is whether or not I will have with ToR and GW2. I just hope they live up to their reputation.
It's just like the console wars for me, I don't give a shit who comes out on top as long as I enjoy the one I choose to play.
 

Kagim

New member
Aug 26, 2009
1,200
0
0
viranimus said:
Kagim said:
4.0 is essentially rebuilding the entire game graphically, and content wise as well, bringing it up to speed with WoTLk which looks fairly good. So instead of treating to crappy computers 5 years ago it will be catering to crappy computers of 2010. Remember a huge selling point of WoW is that older computers can play it on its low settings.

The entire old world is literally being thrown out and replaced with the new one. That's the point of 4.0. To replace the game without replacing the game.
Absolutely and I think its a good thing for WoW, (although 2 out of 3 of the PCs wow has been played on in my house will not be able to handle WoW post cataclysm.) But consider Blizzards turn around time on expansions (which I actually applaud blizzard for) They rebuild the game now, and say this time next year if the conventions TOR adds to the MMO world are starting to stick, do you think Blizzard is going to be inclined to rebuild their world yet again, just to add in something like a cut scene engine or a dialogue matrix? If anything that effort will likely go toward a new MMO project all together.

As for the people who think ToR is just going to be another corpse on the pile in WoWs wake. Sorry, no. Its driven by a company who has a created a niche market, and fueled by two semi linked fanbases, both of which are quite rabid in their own rights. The only thing that will keep ToR from taking over WoWs spot is the fact that it will not appeal to the asian markets the same way WoW has. I see WoW as remaining where they are for a few years to come, but I see ToR overtaking WoW in ENG markets relatively quickly.

And Lets be honest on 2 facts. One blizzard fudges the hell out of their sub numbers. two, WoW Isnt the largest MMO out there.
Oh, i know ToR has a good chance to be popular, but I am not going to say much about it until i see it for myself. However like the few others like my My Galaxies wounds are still there. So i am inclined to be bitter about it.

Now, about cutscenes and cinematics, here is where your clunking.

The majority of WoW players don't like that. The big, massive groups. The throng of the players? They hit accept without reading the quest and used Quest helper to micro manage there way through the game. The majority of the WoW fan base doesn't WANT dialogue matrix's. The majority don't WANT cutscenes. I have seen guilds that say straight out "IF you don't skip the Arthas death cutscene you are disqualified from all loot."

Stuff like that? The WoW players don't want. Have no desire for.

ToR is a single player game at heart, that's what I am getting from most of the stuff i heard.

I mean, look at FFXI. It had dialogue options and cutscenes. It didn't make a lick of difference. Cutscenes in an MMO are nothing new.

Once again, we have to wait till the end results. However i feel we are far from Blizzards 'end of days' and i don't see them existing for only 2 or three more years. Nor do i think ToR will just fall to oblivion, there will be people who want to play it. However I'm not going to make some random guess at numbers, and if a lot of the things people are heralding as nails in WoW's coffin are true, i see them more as things that will drive players away.

Cut scenes and Dialogue just slows down a WoW players exp to time ratio, and they wouldn't like it.

Edit:... I'm sorry if any of that sounds aggressive... it really isn't meant to be....
 

Cyrax987

New member
Aug 3, 2009
250
0
0
migo said:
Star Wars certainly does have the fanbase to potentially beat out WoW, but I'd say Guild Wars 2 is the bigger contender.
As much I like Guild Wars and I'm looking forward to Guild Wars 2, I can't really seeing it being the bigger contender since its still relatively unknown to a lot of people. But I might be wrong.
 

Kagim

New member
Aug 26, 2009
1,200
0
0
Kurokasumi said:
Kagim said:
Kurokasumi said:
Kagim said:
Lancer723 said:
New Players wanting to get into WoW need the original game plus...3 expansions now...4? I can't even remember. Plus the monthly fee

New Players wanting to get into Old Republic only need to buy one game....plus the monthly fee. Still it's newer, has a great universe to build on and is markedly easier to get into, plus everyone's on square one with the new game, instead of having tons of people who have already been playing for years.
Actually many people will be starting from square one with the new expansion, since the starting zones are being rebuilt this expansion lots of players will be experiencing a lot of new content for the first time.

Kurokasumi said:
I think with SW:TOR as well as Guild Wars 2 on the way, I don't think WoW will necessarily 'die' but I think it's population will take a massive nose dive
That's what they said about the last six dozen games that were released...
True, but that's what *they* said. I personally never thought it would happen. This is the first time I actually think WoW might take a dive.
All i am saying is don't hold your breath.

Star wars Galaxies pre-cocking it up(Otherwise known as NGE) was not only star wars, but incredibly unique, fun, and to this day un-emulated in its innovative design of an MMO.

And she got put down. It was nothing like WoW, and she was killed on me. I just don't see anything beating WoW or hurting its population in any permanent way.

Maybe I am bitter. But the way i see this happening is the same thing with Warhammer and Star Trek and LotR. Three Incredibly popular IP's, IP's that were about a thousand times more popular then WoW at its release, that failed to even cough at it threateningly.

That's not to say ToR will not be popular, that's very very likely to happen. Just i don't see millions of people leaving WoW like people are doom saying.
This is what I'm loving about the escapist so far... being able to have conversations with people about things as popular as WoW and not have simple comebacks as 'Lol no f*** u WoW 4evr' I salute you sir.
But on topic, I am not holding my breath in the least, and I could care less if WoW fell or stays right where it is. All I care about is whether or not I will have with ToR and GW2. I just hope they live up to their reputation.
It's just like the console wars for me, I don't give a shit who comes out on top as long as I enjoy the one I choose to play.
No, there's jerks. There's a guy posting in this thread who's trying to troll and get a reaction on this page. People are ignoring him though... Thank god.

You will find the assholes... And the elitists. They hide with knives.
 

migo

New member
Jun 27, 2010
2,698
0
0
Cyrax987 said:
migo said:
Star Wars certainly does have the fanbase to potentially beat out WoW, but I'd say Guild Wars 2 is the bigger contender.
As much I like Guild Wars and I'm looking forward to Guild Wars 2, I can't really seeing it being the bigger contender since its still relatively unknown to a lot of people. But I might be wrong.
Post WoW the only one I can think of is Guild Wars. That's all I ever hear about. I can name plenty of pre WoW RPGs, but since WoW it's World of Warcraft and Guild Wars. Sure there's DDO, but I figure I hear about that since I play D&D.
 

Samus Aaron

New member
Apr 3, 2010
364
0
0
No. Just no. WOW is much too big of a monolith. Watch Extra Credits if you want it explained better for you.
 

Entropyutd

New member
Apr 12, 2010
189
0
0
Wolfram01 said:
Given that WoW has yet another expansion, and this one making some of the biggest changes yet, I don't think anything will topple it for a while. Old Republic will probably be good (although people said the same about SW: Galaxies which didn't do so well) but it won't beat WoW.
I agree.
Wasnt so long ago people were getting huge boners over the Star Trek MMO, which if the last time I played it is anything to go by, is dead. (And still as laggy as hell)
(a couple of months ago)

WoW has a subscription base of over 6 million, and you have to figure a large percentage of that have at least one maxxed out character, all set for the new expansion.
I seriously doubt any new MMO has the clout to sell 6 million units, even Star Wars.

WoW has built its base over a 5 year period with quality expansions and content.
It is going to take Blizzard dropping the ball and a competitor to be good enough and dedicated enough to build the subscriber base over a similar period of time to even get close to achieving what Blizzard has with WoW.
 

mrdude2010

New member
Aug 6, 2009
1,315
0
0
Space Spoons said:
Honestly, I don't think anything less than World of StarCraft has the power to stop the beast that WoW has become.
god of halo: world of starcraft 4 modern warfare
 

Romblen

New member
Oct 10, 2009
871
0
0
I doubt it will kill World of Warcraft. For every MMO that comes out now, there's always at least one person predicting it will spell the end for World of Warcraft. I'm not saying Knights of the Old Republic won't be popular, I just doubt this will really affect World of Warcraft. As long as more expansion packs are made for World of Warcraft, it will still be popular.
 

thedeathscythe

New member
Aug 6, 2010
754
0
0
I can see it doing well, but I doubt it'll hurt it too bad. Star Trek has a huge following and the MMO hasn't done too well. Now, Star Wars is being made by Bioware, so they also have that, but Blizzard has that new expansion...y'enno, it's tough to say, it'll be real interesting to see, and if it does, to see how Blizzard fights back. I'm gonna say it won't effect them, though.
 

Kavonde

Usually Neutral Good
Feb 8, 2010
323
0
0
World of Warcraft isn't going to be dethroned. And I don't mean "not for a long time," I mean, it may very well reign over all MMO's for decades to come.

The key is this: there are too many people who have invested too much time and money into WoW to stop playing. Oh, they might cancel their account for a few months, or grow up, get married, and have kids...but they'll be back. And they'll bring their wife, and their kids, and their dog if they can figure out how. As long as Blizzard keeps producing new, quality content and making the game a little bit better and a little bit prettier as time goes on, World of Wacraft will never die.

Search your feelings. You know this to be true.