Is gaming bad for your mental health?

Recommended Videos

Woodsey

New member
Aug 9, 2009
14,553
0
0
derelix said:
Woodsey said:
As long as you're capable of balancing things in your life, then games aren't a problem. They can only have the same impact on your health if you sit in a room alone for all your life and only play games; but substitute "play games" for "read books" and it's the same story, which I think a lot of people overlook when they talk about gaming from the outside.

I'd say they're likely more stimulating for your brain then books and TV are at any rate.
I would say no. Tv maybe but not books. You have to actually think to enjoy books (yes even stupid ones) but games have everything laid out for you. No imagination needed.
More stimulating? Seems like a pretty bold statement with no logic or explanation. It's like saying Pepsi might be healthier than orange juice.
Explanation? No. Logic? Yes.

You could argue that books and games are on a par, but if you're playing a (good) game, then you'll often have multiple things to keep in mind. There's a lot of stuff that you're simply taking in without focusing on too (say, the amount of ammo you have left in your gun). Sure, a book's got reading and imagination, but good games have reading, interaction, observation, problem-solving, tactics, etc. etc.
 

The_ModeRazor

New member
Jul 29, 2009
2,837
0
0
Hmm, you kinda remind me of me.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure I'd have been much more popular in primary school if I didn't get introduced to gaming. And the "bitter misanthrope" probably fits a bit too. Luckily, these days I don't get bullied (not just because school hasn't started yet) because most people think I'm pretty funny and... generally capable of shutting everyone the fuck up with a properly punctuated (read: full of swear words) argument.
I shall find me a time machine, and turn me into a people of mass destruction awesome by killing Neumann János!
 

Ascaryrobot

New member
Aug 3, 2010
19
0
0
If I didn't take up gaming I would have been the one who went postal and killed everyone in his post code. Really. Before I sat down in front of a game I was heading rapidly down the "angry, lonely, evil little bastard" route, I first sat down before Sonic 2 in 1994 (aged 3) and fell in love with games.

They really are the only thing that keep me sane since I can't stand the social rules and expectations we have in this day and age. In other words video games do effect you mentally, but not always in a bad way.
 

Not-here-anymore

In brightest day...
Nov 18, 2009
3,028
0
0
Famine0 said:
J03bot said:
I feel I've had the opposite effect. Gaming has given me a series of objectives, which I've needed to help me through my (also diagnosed by a doctor) depression.
Although I suppose, for reasons I've never understood, I don't appear to have the social problems you seem to have.
All things in moderation, I suppose. If you can balance your gaming with a social life, then, (as with any hobby, as long as it doesn't become an obsession), it can improve your mental health, simply by alleviating boredom, or giving you something that can be talked about with others, even if only with a small group.
I won't be so brash as to suggest that suddenly making friends is easy though. As I said, I have no idea how I acquired a social life. It just sort of happened.
I have to admit that gaming can be good also. I wouldn't have been nearly as "smart" if it weren't for gaming. Also I wouldn't have learned to speak english... But I'm curious as to what sort of objectives gaming has given you?
I don't mean in terms of life goals when I say objectives.
Whilst in the depths of depression, I had no real drive to do... well, anything. Not even game, really. But since it was something I did, I built into something like a routine. Games tend to have objectives, at least in some way. (sandbox games didn't help at all...) By completing objectives in games, I felt like some kind of progression was happening, even if it wasn't in my own life. It helped me, even if it meant I had to objectivise my real life to a large degree.
 

Ava Elzbieta

New member
Mar 22, 2010
130
0
0
Well OP, you have my sympathies. I'm sorry to hear you're struggling with a panic disorder, and it's even tougher to battle that while you're already navigating the perils of school. A lot of what you experience is very common among all sorts of people. A large slice of any given populace will have been bullied relentlessly, have difficulty navigating the social waters and self-image issues. If this was an outdoorsman forum, I'd venture there would still be people with similar experiences. Chin up, be strong: these years will not last forever. I won't be the first nor the last to tell you this, but as much as it might feel you're in the depths of hell now, this too shall pass. Think of whatever stresses are in your everyday life in the long term: will this matter to me a year from now? two years? ten years? I promise you, once you graduate, the faces that seem to be everywhere now will fade away and you will never, ever hear from them again. I mean, ever. This life is long and hard, but you will pull through and be the man you want to be. Think of these years as a trial, the social experiences you have now will be like hurdles and tests to help you cope with college and a job. With every day you'll get a little better and a lot stronger. Have faith in yourself and everything else will fall into place.

J03bot said:
I feel I've had the opposite effect. Gaming has given me a series of objectives, which I've needed to help me through my (also diagnosed by a doctor) depression.
I'll defend gaming for many reasons, and this is one of them. As derelix mentioned, humans aren't meant to be crammed into tiny cubicles, hammering away at buttons and squinting at blinking monitors all day long. Gaming gives us an outlet, something achievable to give definition and goals, and an escape. There were many reasons I found refuge in gaming as a child (bullying was indeed one of them), and even more why I enjoy it as an adult. It is a large part of my life, but it does not come at the cost of my relationships with romantic partners, friends or family: if anything it enhances them. Many of my best friends have been met through conversations about gaming, and it's an easy common ground to mention when meeting new people, as almost everyone enjoys games of a sort, even if it was marathons of Space Invaders at the arcade or playing backgammon at the kitchen table.

TLDR: No, gaming is not bad for your mental health. In fact, countless studies have suggested it improves one's mental and physical health. Individuals with psychiatric disorders enjoy all sorts of hobbies, and gaming might be one of the only ones that will help them.
 

Ascaryrobot

New member
Aug 3, 2010
19
0
0
I was introverted and spent most of my time pushing over other kids, hitting adults and generally hurting people. Total dickweed mode, so yeah, yeah I was on the path to "evil" (read: bullying arsehole)
 

Poofs

New member
Nov 16, 2009
594
0
0
id say it hasnt effected me
ive been gaming since i was around 8, and i mean like staying up til 4am to finish that last level on Goldeneye, gaming
and i have never had issues like you describe
i have decently high self-esteem
i have a rather large group of friends i routinely hang out with
i dont have any mental, or social problems
i bathe at least once a day

i just think these issues are more personal than gaming caused

also i am desensitized so ill give you that one, though that was /b/, not video games
 

Ascaryrobot

New member
Aug 3, 2010
19
0
0
Yes of course, deriving enjoyment from tossing small children to the ground, what a delightful shade of gray.
And please don't belittle my intelligence by suggesting I fall for that movie horseshit, I still get flashes of those feelings and they're not like anger or even sadism, it's just and urge to go hurt someone else, playing waving videogames allowed me to fulfill all my darker pleasures in simulation and low and behold I became the respectable, if slightly unbalanced person I am today.

I know it's hard to believe a child can be a little bastard but please remember, there's 6-7 billion people in the world, just because you have (may have) the emotional range of a teaspoon you should be able to grasp that other people experience things you can't even imagine.
 

Ascaryrobot

New member
Aug 3, 2010
19
0
0
Are you really so intellectually vapid that you think everyone is exactly the same? You can't really be so stupid? Of course, no one could possibly be a socially inept, angry introverted bastard. Everyone has to be just like you and because you're not special no one can have any sort of difference than your idealistic "norm"?

Projecting so hard if you shoved a roll of film up your arse we could use you a a home theater.
 

Ace of Spades

New member
Jul 12, 2008
3,303
0
0
Generic Gamer said:
Well yes I honestly do think that they affect your mental health. Not because of what they are but because of what they're not.

People need social interaction, we're built around it and if we don't have it (sorry guys) we go very odd. Gaming isn't social, not the kind of social we need and if you spend hours at a time playing games you won't develop life skills. If you've got no friends and you game instead you're exacerbating the problem, not solving it.
I find this post exceptionally ironic considering that your name is Generic Gamer.