Marines Desecrate Insurgent corpse, urinate on it

Recommended Videos

Elementary - Dear Watson

RIP Eleuthera, I will miss you
Nov 9, 2010
2,980
0
0
Daystar Clarion said:
Smeggs said:
I'm not even going to look at the Youtube comments.

I can aready pretty accurately guess what I'll find.

"Americans are fucking pigs, go die."
"WE DE BEST CUNTRY EVUR!"
"The [Insert Countryman] would never do something like that."
"*Someone pulls out historic instances of said country's cruelty*"
And so on and so forth.
And my personal favourite.

'That's nothing, you should have seen what I did to your mum last night.'
Then you are forgetting that the entire conversation will collapse under 9/11 conspiricy theories, copied and pasted from other pages with the care and attention of a 6 year old cut and stick homework!

This will then in turn merge into an arguement about whether Iraq was justified (because lets face it, most people think Iraq and Afghanistan are the same war...) and eventually the only comments appearing will be one sad fucker who thinks he knows everything about the subject (but is actually a delusional bastard who just happenes to be surprisingly good at expressing their points with a good use of grammer and spelling) experessing over and over different points that may or may not be backed by fact, until a fair few pages of comments are takien up by just them, and the occasional arrow in the knee joke!
 

cthulhuspawn82

New member
Oct 16, 2011
321
0
0
I have a question for anyone who responds to this video by saying that US Marines are evil disgusting pigs. How do you sleep soundly at night with all those evil black people out there?

Here me out on this. You have people who believe that Marines are vile and disgusting because of one or two cases of a few Marines doing vile and disgusting things. I know I can link to at least two or three news stories where a black guy rapped or murdered someone. According to the same twisted logic, couldn't you say that those two or three news stories prove that black people are brutal savages that rape and murder without remorse? And would you not have reason to believe that the black family living down the street is a threat to your life?

Unless of course a few isolated instances don't actually influence people opinions about a group, but rather are used by people who already held those opinions to reinforce their own crazy logic.
 
Dec 14, 2009
15,526
0
0
DeanoTheGod said:
Daystar Clarion said:
Smeggs said:
I'm not even going to look at the Youtube comments.

I can aready pretty accurately guess what I'll find.

"Americans are fucking pigs, go die."
"WE DE BEST CUNTRY EVUR!"
"The [Insert Countryman] would never do something like that."
"*Someone pulls out historic instances of said country's cruelty*"
And so on and so forth.
And my personal favourite.

'That's nothing, you should have seen what I did to your mum last night.'
Then you are forgetting that the entire conversation will collapse under 9/11 conspiricy theories, copied and pasted from other pages with the care and attention of a 6 year old cut and stick homework!

This will then in turn merge into an arguement about whether Iraq was justified (because lets face it, most people think Iraq and Afghanistan are the same war...) and eventually the only comments appearing will be one sad fucker who thinks he knows everything about the subject (but is actually a delusional bastard who just happenes to be surprisingly good at expressing their points with a good use of grammer and spelling) experessing over and over different points that may or may not be backed by fact, until a fair few pages of comments are takien up by just them, and the occasional arrow in the knee joke!
And a partridge in a pear treeeeeeeee!

That was fun, let's do it again sometime.
 

BonsaiK

Music Industry Corporate Whore
Nov 14, 2007
5,635
0
0
Okay so over 24 hours after I reported it, this thread is still up with inexplicably no moderator action to remove the video.

Therefore, as promised in previous posts in this thread, bye bye, Escapists. It's been fun.

Don't bother replying to this, I won't be reading.

Oh and:

manic_depressive13 said:
I'm glad that this is a website where I can find news and not just threads full of bad relationship advice and people gloating that negative publicity for crappy music is equivalent to positive publicity as if no one else has figured it out, and as if they weren't already internet sensations before they found their way to this site.
Given that I'm leaving I could theoretically say anything I wanted to here without consequences, but I always prided myself in not doing such things. So all I'll say is that I'm glad my legacy here was memorable to some folks, for better or worse.
 

almostgold

New member
Dec 1, 2009
729
0
0
Dammit, this is the sort of shit the insurgents do. Not the United States Marine Corps. I'm also disappointed in the way this is gonna make the Corps look, especially in the eyes of the American public. I'm also also disappointed in the failing of intelligence for these Marines to film it...I mean, DAMN, doing it is immoral, but filming it is just astoundingly stupid.

Most of all, definitely pissed about my first point. The fact that we treat the enemy more humanely than they treat us sets us apart, and above, from them. Shit like this takes away that distinction.
 

Zio_IV

Not a Premium Member
Sep 17, 2011
178
0
0
Krion_Vark said:
Zio_IV said:
I did 4 years in the Marines and you know what I found out in that span of time?

Marines are mostly scum. A good number of them are the exact opposite of the sort of people the GP (General Population) think would join up. Of course there are a few decent people here and there as well (as with any facet of society, really), but all things considered, the majority of people I met during my time in the corps were not the greatest.

I guess that's just my long-winded way of saying that I'm not surprised by this video. I've seen stuff just as bad in person, honestly.
My only question is what was your MOS.
I don't really think it matters, does it? The opinions I've stated came from my experience with all the different jobs in the corps, from admin to infantry, and (almost) everything in between.

Besides, with the way you ask your question, you give off the impression of someone who is still in the corps and maybe wants to find the people I'm talking about so you can give them a negative counseling or whatever. I'm not saying that's your intention, but that's the way you're coming off.
 

Xan Krieger

Completely insane
Feb 11, 2009
2,918
0
0
War is Hell as general William T Sherman once said. This sort of thing happens and it's normal for something so traumatic. They need therapy, as do many people who fought over there. This is not a criminal case because of course all's fair in love and war (and of course the geneva convention only applies to the losers).
 

sonofliber

New member
Mar 8, 2010
245
0
0
so... whats new about this?, unless you are extremely naive you know this things happen, so does rape and murder by ocupation forces (or the rebel forces trying to "protect" their home), who knows what those marines have been through?, this ofcouse doesnt help their image with the local population who see their country invaded, their homes destroyed, people they care or knew raped, tortured or killed, and are left wanting revenge.



also are you sure this guys are insurgents? or we just have to take those guys word for it?.


p.s: sorry for the bad english
 

BeretedWalrus

New member
Jan 12, 2012
4
0
0
Xan Krieger said:
War is Hell as general William T Sherman once said. This sort of thing happens and it's normal for something so traumatic. They need therapy, as do many people who fought over there. This is not a criminal case because of course all's fair in love and war (and of course the geneva convention only applies to the losers).
...I can't even begin to tell you what was wrong with that post. If war is hell, then what does that make the Marines in the video?

Also, I'm pretty sure the Geneva Convention applies to everyone. Hell, even the Nazis in WWII allowed care packages through to POWs. What those dumb jarheads did in that video is a disgrace to the entirety of the United States Armed Forces.

sonofliber said:
so... whats new about this?, unless you are extremely naive you know this things happen, so does rape and murder by ocupation forces (or the rebel forces trying to "protect" their home), who knows what those marines have been through?, this ofcouse doesnt help their image with the local population who see their country invaded, their homes destroyed, people they care or knew raped, tortured or killed, and are left wanting revenge.



also are you sure this guys are insurgents? or we just have to take those guys word for it?.


p.s: sorry for the bad english
The horrible thing is that in the Western world, we see our soldiers as our heroes, our knights in shining armour. We don't expect to see them desecrating corpses.

Also, I hope those were insurgents. Otherwise, if they just killed a bunch of civilians for fun, I will have officially lost hope in humanity.
 

IamQ

New member
Mar 29, 2009
5,226
0
0
slopeslider said:
Seems it's not a war crime or anything
Seems a bit weird you can piss on dead guys but not shoot them with a hollowpoints
Yeah man, I agree. I mean, killing them? that's fine, but taking a leak on them? Now that's crossing the line.
 

the clockmaker

New member
Jun 11, 2010
423
0
0
BeretedWalrus said:
...I can't even begin to tell you what was wrong with that post. If war is hell, then what does that make the Marines in the video?

Also, I'm pretty sure the Geneva Convention applies to everyone. Hell, even the Nazis in WWII allowed care packages through to POWs. What those dumb jarheads did in that video is a disgrace to the entirety of the United States Armed Forces.
No value judgement intended, (these morons are a part of the reason the yanks are having trouble with hearts and minds) but the geneva convention protects civilians, POWs and enemy soldiers. If you are fighting in civilian clothing, you are not protected by the geneva convention
 

BeretedWalrus

New member
Jan 12, 2012
4
0
0
the clockmaker said:
BeretedWalrus said:
...I can't even begin to tell you what was wrong with that post. If war is hell, then what does that make the Marines in the video?

Also, I'm pretty sure the Geneva Convention applies to everyone. Hell, even the Nazis in WWII allowed care packages through to POWs. What those dumb jarheads did in that video is a disgrace to the entirety of the United States Armed Forces.
No value judgement intended, (these morons are a part of the reason the yanks are having trouble with hearts and minds) but the geneva convention protects civilians, POWs and enemy soldiers. If you are fighting in civilian clothing, you are not protected by the geneva convention
Quite right. Perhaps I was a bit loose with the term "everyone".

However, I think just having to say "don't urinate on dead bodies" to professional soldiers seems a bit silly. It's just common sense, and they blatantly violated it.
 

Xan Krieger

Completely insane
Feb 11, 2009
2,918
0
0
BeretedWalrus said:
Xan Krieger said:
War is Hell as general William T Sherman once said. This sort of thing happens and it's normal for something so traumatic. They need therapy, as do many people who fought over there. This is not a criminal case because of course all's fair in love and war (and of course the geneva convention only applies to the losers).
...I can't even begin to tell you what was wrong with that post. If war is hell, then what does that make the Marines in the video?

Also, I'm pretty sure the Geneva Convention applies to everyone. Hell, even the Nazis in WWII allowed care packages through to POWs. What those dumb jarheads did in that video is a disgrace to the entirety of the United States Armed Forces.

sonofliber said:
so... whats new about this?, unless you are extremely naive you know this things happen, so does rape and murder by ocupation forces (or the rebel forces trying to "protect" their home), who knows what those marines have been through?, this ofcouse doesnt help their image with the local population who see their country invaded, their homes destroyed, people they care or knew raped, tortured or killed, and are left wanting revenge.



also are you sure this guys are insurgents? or we just have to take those guys word for it?.


p.s: sorry for the bad english
The horrible thing is that in the Western world, we see our soldiers as our heroes, our knights in shining armour. We don't expect to see them desecrating corpses.

Also, I hope those were insurgents. Otherwise, if they just killed a bunch of civilians for fun, I will have officially lost hope in humanity.
Here's what I meant by the geneva convention thing. Germany and Japan broke the rules and got prosecuted. The soviet union broke them on a near constant basis and nothing happened.
 

Fishyash

Elite Member
Dec 27, 2010
1,154
0
41
Bad enough that this happens, and probably happens quite often.

But it's nothing short of retarded to have it recorded. It's already been on the news and there has been some backlash already. The whole of taliban and afghanistan (not to mention even some US citezens) probably think less of US marines now.
 

x EvilErmine x

Cake or death?!
Apr 5, 2010
1,022
0
0
Kopikatsu said:
I can't say that I care this happened. The Taliban guys are dead, so it's not like they're in any position to care about what happens to their corpses. On the same token, my reaction would be the same if it were the Taliban doing this to dead marines. Dead people really don't care about all that much, yanno?
No the point dude, it's not about what the dead think of it. It's about what we as the living think. Although they may have been the 'enemy' they were people who had mothers and fathers, probably siblings and maybe a wife and children who loved them. To treat a dead body with no respect like that is just wrong, it's not about what side that person was on when they were alive it's about being human.

OT
While I know that's not the first time that this kind of thing has happened, on both sides of the conflict. It's still very bad. America likes to claim it's this beacon for democracy, justice and civilization yet this footage makes it very hard not to think otherwise. Had this been an isolated incident then it could be written off, however it's not, there have been tones of videos showing how badly human rights have been violated over the course of the war. I know there will be people who think that because the Taliban have done the same and worse to American soldiers that this somehow makes it ok, an eye for an eye right? No not at all, if America wants to claim that it's better than the Taliban then it needs to cut this kinda shit out because it's doing them no favours at all. You cant go claiming that you are the better side when you act just like the enemy.
 

GeneWard

New member
Feb 23, 2011
277
0
0
x EvilErmine x said:
Kopikatsu said:
No the point dude, it's not about what the dead think of it. It's about what we as the living think. Although they may have been the 'enemy' they were people who had mothers and fathers, probably siblings and maybe a wife and children who loved them. To treat a dead body with no respect like that is just wrong, it's not about what side that person was on when they were alive it's about being human.
The way I see it, dude, they aren't people any more once they're dead. I'd say the more morally reprehensible act here is killing them in the first place. Once you're dead, you aren't "You" any more. You're just a pile of skin, fat, bone and blood. You have no personality, you know? The body is just a vessel of life, nothing more, and once you're dead, you're just a dangerous, septic piece of garbage. I don't get people being attached to corpses or remains...
 

Krion_Vark

New member
Mar 25, 2010
1,700
0
0
Zio_IV said:
Krion_Vark said:
Zio_IV said:
I did 4 years in the Marines and you know what I found out in that span of time?

Marines are mostly scum. A good number of them are the exact opposite of the sort of people the GP (General Population) think would join up. Of course there are a few decent people here and there as well (as with any facet of society, really), but all things considered, the majority of people I met during my time in the corps were not the greatest.

I guess that's just my long-winded way of saying that I'm not surprised by this video. I've seen stuff just as bad in person, honestly.
My only question is what was your MOS.
I don't really think it matters, does it? The opinions I've stated came from my experience with all the different jobs in the corps, from admin to infantry, and (almost) everything in between.

Besides, with the way you ask your question, you give off the impression of someone who is still in the corps and maybe wants to find the people I'm talking about so you can give them a negative counseling or whatever. I'm not saying that's your intention, but that's the way you're coming off.
Actually no. My brother was in the Corp but got out this past July. My friends exboyfriend is still in the corp. The people my brother met are all good/decent people while the people my friends exboyfriend knows are all kind of douchebags. The difference there is that my brother worked on vehicles while my friends exboyfriend is an infantryman. I was just wondering if it had to do with your MOS or maybe its just the group that was around you all the time.
 

Zio_IV

Not a Premium Member
Sep 17, 2011
178
0
0
Krion_Vark said:
Zio_IV said:
Krion_Vark said:
Zio_IV said:
I did 4 years in the Marines and you know what I found out in that span of time?

Marines are mostly scum. A good number of them are the exact opposite of the sort of people the GP (General Population) think would join up. Of course there are a few decent people here and there as well (as with any facet of society, really), but all things considered, the majority of people I met during my time in the corps were not the greatest.

I guess that's just my long-winded way of saying that I'm not surprised by this video. I've seen stuff just as bad in person, honestly.
My only question is what was your MOS.
I don't really think it matters, does it? The opinions I've stated came from my experience with all the different jobs in the corps, from admin to infantry, and (almost) everything in between.

Besides, with the way you ask your question, you give off the impression of someone who is still in the corps and maybe wants to find the people I'm talking about so you can give them a negative counseling or whatever. I'm not saying that's your intention, but that's the way you're coming off.
Actually no. My brother was in the Corp but got out this past July. My friends exboyfriend is still in the corp. The people my brother met are all good/decent people while the people my friends exboyfriend knows are all kind of douchebags. The difference there is that my brother worked on vehicles while my friends exboyfriend is an infantryman. I was just wondering if it had to do with your MOS or maybe its just the group that was around you all the time.
Alright, fair enough, no ill will intended. The only reason I made that accusation is because most higher-ups would relish the chance to cause a scandal and generally make their subordinate's lives worse, and they do use the internet to look for potential cases and such. I've seen more than enough of said cases that I've become slightly paranoid about stuff like that (not necessarily without good reason, though). But hey, that's another story not related to this topic.

In any case, to answer your question, I was in logistics, 0481 specifically. I worked along plenty of motor T and mechanics because of it. A few of them were pretty decent people. You are right in thinking that those in that line of work (fixing vehicles and whatnot) are somewhat relaxed. They certainly are in comparison to a lot of other jobs. Infantry, on the other hand, is a very strange mixed bag. Some are nice, most are dicks, but all are missing a screw or two. I personally attribute that to the job, though. Not the fighting part, however, most grunts are actually okay with all that. No, the thing that makes grunts a little screwy is all the stupid ridiculous training they have to do when they're NOT fighting. I mean hell, I've had rough times in the corps, like a 9-month period where I was ganged up on and beaten every week just for being the new guy, but grunts? They probably have it worse overall.

The thing that the public doesn't see is that most Marines hate their job and want to get out. This is true of all jobs, and all ranks (it just means it took them longer to realise it) but the reason for this is not because of fighting, like a lot of people I've talked to about this have thought. No, it's because the daily life of a marine sucks. I spent 4 years in there, did two deployments during that time frame, and the only marketable skill any of us practised on a daily basis were janitorial skills. Rest assured, when you join the Marine Corps, even if you are infantry, you will hold a broom more than you ever hold a gun. And when you're not training, you do nothing. You don't get to go home if there's nothing to. You get to stay at work and twiddle your thumbs for the whole 10-14 hours you spend at your workplace. And since the whole "marine" thing is to always be doing something, this causes higher-ups to create meaningless tasks for the workforce to carry out for no reason other than "Well, we can't just send you home, can we?" Most of the time they will have you do the opposite of something you had just finished doing eg. taking apart a vehicle after just having finished putting it together at the same person's request.

That is how most days play out in the corps, for ALL jobs (except maybe admin). It causes marines to become disgruntled and overall creates rifts in boss-subordinate relations, resulting in reduced motivation and productivity. This wouldn't be so much of a problem, if it weren't a corps-wide phenomenon. Everywhere you go, from Pendleton to Okinawa, you hear the same story from every marine you come across. It's also part of the reason why even some of the nicer marines turn into dicks over time (like me).

Wow, I ended up saying way more than I thought I would.

TL;DR: Most marines are jerkwads because the job itself freaking sucks.