Snotnarok said:
Lord of the Rings, the sheer amount of plot holes drove me insane. Don't give me "you have to read the books" or "You have to know some more of the lore" to fill in the holes, it's 9+ hours worth of movie, if it can't stand up alone by itself with that amount of time then perhaps they could have cut out some parts. Like the elf going rambo in a battle taking out battle elephants and whatever.
Seriously that part just made me rage, I know they're supposed to be elite and all that, but why wasn't he and the other elite groups killing more like that?
And Gamdalf is supposed to be a mage but the only real spell I saw him cast was magic flashlight. How about a firewall? A confuse spell, something that makes him actually LOOK like a mage. (yes he knocked the weapons out of their hands at one point, and force threw Saroman around but come on)
Beautiful? Sure. Epic battles? Some. Weird plotholes? Yes.
(Sigh) I'm sorry for doing this--and I'm sure I'm about to annoy many people--but I feel I must speak. I agree to a point on the elves--or rather, elf. If Legolas can do all these amazing stunts, why were the elves at Helm's Deep being slaughtered? Shouldn't they be just as good? However, they weren't at the elephant battle (Pelennor Fields), so that's why he was the only one taking them out.
Gandalf is not a mage by today's D&D standards. Tolkien believed that magic was reserved for Higher Power (God), and that magic used by mortals was evil. Witch craft. So, he made went to great pains to limit the use of magic in his books, at least by the heroes. Now, Gandalf is allowed to use magic--as you pointed out--because he is not human, but one of five guardian angels sent to Middle Earth. However, he and the others use their magic sparingly, if at all, because of Tolkien's view on the subject.
I'm curious about other plots holes you noticed, if you want to take the time to list them.