Poll: Cross Platform Multiplayer?

[Assassin Xaero]

They tried it with PC and 360, and even with average PC gamers vs "pro" 360 gamers, the 360 gamers got raped. Put, some games do already have it, like Lost Plant Colonies Edition. And for cross-console play, that would probably require an agreement between Sony and Microsoft that I doubt either would want.

 

[Owyn_Merrilin]

Sure, maybe.

What controller and games do you use? (if any)

Well, erm, okay. I use the 360 controller for shooters (and, therefore, buy them for the 360), the PS3 one for driving games and the PC one for Steam games.

Eh. Really, I think that those forced to play, for example, Killzone 2 with the PS3 controller against someone playing it with the 360 one are in clear disadvantage.

Again, that's probably just me.

That probably is just you. The 360 controller is a dual shock controller with some slight changes to the shoulder buttons, and the location of the D-pad and left analog stick switched. The controllers are similar enough that it comes down completely to personal preference; personally, I don't care for Xbox style controllers, and do much better with Dual Shock variants. The situation becomes a bit different when you include the Wii Mote/Nunchuck combo and the Mouse/Keyboard combo.

I seem to remember Gamecube controller users kicking the butts of the people stuck with a Wiimote and Nunchuck at Super Smash Brothers Brawl, but I doubt there would be much difference between the Gamecube controller and the Classic controller, or the Gamecube contoller and the 360 controller, in a hypothetical situation where it could be connected to the Wii. The Gamecube controller is just different enough from the other controllers that I can see a multiplatform game doing better on the other controllers, but translating a first party Nintendo game to another controller shouldn't be too difficult, since the other controllers have the necessary buttons, just a more even placement of them.

 

[Kair]

Do you really want the PC players to dominate console players in multiplayer?

 

[cricketlenny]

The only problem I can see is the companies working together. If they could try it just once, they could actually make more than they would seperately.

 

[nomadic_chad]

It'd be a slaughter of consolers world wide. I'd love it. Then again, any game that hoped to be a financial success would have to over-enhance the console auto-aim mechanic just to keep it somewhere near fair.

Full disclosure, I play PC and all consoles...even the Wii.

 

[captaincabbage]

Sure, maybe.

What controller and games do you use? (if any)

Well, erm, okay. I use the 360 controller for shooters (and, therefore, buy them for the 360), the PS3 one for driving games and the PC one for Steam games.

Eh. Really, I think that those forced to play, for example, Killzone 2 with the PS3 controller against someone playing it with the 360 one are in clear disadvantage.

Again, that's probably just me.

lol maybe it's just you.
I seem to kick a whole lot of arse with my PS3 controller, but I'm rubbish with a 360 controller in my hands.
I reckon it's a lot more to do with what you learnt on than what's a more ergonomic controller.

Admittedly, I'm pretty glad we don't have cross-platform gaming. Every time I've gone online with my friend's 360, every match we go onto seems to be populated by either whiney 12yo kids, or irritating and obnoxious teenagers. My friend has had to quit quite a few sessions online just because people wouldn't stop harassing her.
We usually play Red Dead Redemption (on expert of course. Is there any other way?), Halo 3, Crackdown 2, Rainbow 6 Vegas 2 or Modern Warfare 2.

She's never gotten the same problems on my PS3 when she plays on her profile at my place, and we play mostly the same games (RDR, R6V2, MW2, KZ2. Tho I don't really play MW2 anymore)

 

[Atmos Duality]

Actually...

Spoiler: Nintendo did it already between the Wii and DS.

Plus, when I played, it didn't require me to put in those "Friend Codes". Don't count them out yet.

OT: I'd actually like to see more of this happen. It'd be cool to kind of meld the gaming communities together.

And you have proved that Nintendo is perfectly happy with collaborating...with itself. Which wasn't really my point to begin with.

Most cross-platform titles that matter will be between systems not owned by the same company.

 

[Dana22]

Eh. I don't know. I think that it's really about the controllers and I think that some controllers might be better suited for a certain game than others - giving some players a disadvantage.

But, hey, it's an alright idea - just not something console developers would want to do.

Maybe, but if you own the console and the game, you should be pretty damn efficient with that controller, so I don't think it would matter at all.

That doesn't matter, certain controllers are still inferior when compared to others, simply because of technical limitations.

Can you give me some examples?

Analog stick is not as precise as mouse. Thats the reason for various auto-aims and assists in console games.

 

[captaincabbage]

Eh. I don't know. I think that it's really about the controllers and I think that some controllers might be better suited for a certain game than others - giving some players a disadvantage.

But, hey, it's an alright idea - just not something console developers would want to do.

Maybe, but if you own the console and the game, you should be pretty damn efficient with that controller, so I don't think it would matter at all.

That doesn't matter, certain controllers are still inferior when compared to others, simply because of technical limitations.

Can you give me some examples?

Analog stick is not as precise as mouse. Thats the reason for various auto-aims and assists in console games.

I thought we were talking about consoles, not PCs. In that case, yeah obviously a mouse and keyboard would pwn, but if there was some kind of cross console multiplayer (xbox and PS3) I don't see what the problem would be, aside from developers not being stuffed.

On the other hand,

apparently, you just plug it in and the PS3 registers it as a normal controller, which is awesome.
here's the website. www.splitfish.com

 

[joemegson94]

It shouldn't be done. If the Xbox Live players were in contact with Nintendo WFC's users, there'd be a lot of crying children and a lot of Wiimotes hurled across rooms.

 

[fix-the-spade]

Mo, I don't want XBox Live players on my PC games. I want to spend time playing and not banning people...

 

[PuffyMuffin92]

I may have missed this but can this actually be done for a ps3 and 360? is it technically possible?

 

[Vilcus]

I'm all for it. Got a buddy who has several games I own, but he has them for the Ps3 while I own them for the 360, so that would make it so he doesn't have to buy a 360 if he ever wants to play a game with me (I'm not budging on the matter, a new computer, and basically everything else comes before purchasing a Ps3). Too bad they'll never go back and add cross platform multiplayer to older games.

 

[Sn1P3r M98]

Ever played Shadowrun?

Grrr. Ninjas!

Well, I'll throw a pic in anyways.

 

[zfactor]

I may have missed this but can this actually be done for a ps3 and 360? is it technically possible?

Not sure...

There might be networking differences (they are two different operating systems, after all). But I don't know if that matters because they are going to the same server... I'm pretty sure it is possible (especially with PC and 360, microsoft makes the software for both, XBL is probably the same system as GFWL, even though the latter sucks balls) but nobody has done it yet. And I don't know why. Because I would buy a mediocre shooter if it means I can play my friend with a 360.

 

[Iron Mal]

I've heard about a game that tried that once, and apparently they never tried it again because the PC users wiped their ass with the competition.

This pretty much sums up the reason why we shouldn't have cross platform multiplayer.

People would just give each other endless abuse over their choice of console (just like the fellow in the quote above who is probably in need of having his head surgically extracted from his rectum).

In short, we're way, way too 'territorial' to just be able to play nice together.

 

[Singularly Datarific]

true, but if there was a leader board based on what platform your on, and see which platform has the best players, you could settle the console wars a little more quickly. And PC gamers, the reason your "better" is because you have a mouse. if you turn down its speed to match our controlers, and then you beat us, youll have the proof you need. but untill that happens, just keep those comments about us "consoletards" to yourself.

Also, PC and Console FPS'es's are built differently. Console ones are built around timing and cycles; hide behind the wall, pop up and take potshots while the other guy stops shooting, repeat. Or the left-trigger aim-locking, such as in Metroid Prime, or, in a lesser extend, COD.
PC has no hiding or timing. It's only a matter of time before a bunnyhopping shotgunner pops out of the corner and blasts you where you cower, so it relies far more on snap movements and quick aim. Also, you get called a camper if you wait in one place for more than 14 seconds.