JeanLuc761 said:
Arctarus said:
JeanLuc761 said:
Unless the game is playing itself for you, every single game in existence requires skill on one level or another. Whether it's Portal 2 which requires critical thinking skills, Call of Duty which requires fast reflexes, precision and tactical thinking, or even Plants vs. Zombies which requires proper utilization of resources and strategic placement of defenses, all games require skill.
Are you sure we're talking about the same Call of Duty? Its mostly run, shoot, die, complain about lag, and then someone throws in the occasional racial slurs.
Edit: Games that do require skill would be most fighting games unless you just mash all the buttons and games like Portal I guess.
I'm referring more to the first Modern Warfare, but regardless, all Call of Duty's require some measure of skill. This is more obvious in the singleplayer; multiplayer is more "I saw you first!"
Ehhh, I'm still not bying the "tactical thinking", and partly not even fast reflexes. Every CoD (possibly excluding MW2, which I haven't played, but I've heard it's more open than other CoDs) is extremely linear in design, so the only "tactics" for the player to use are the ones the game specifically tells you to. Run there, pick up better weapon, get to turret, shoot the tanks with this RPG, now escape. I once played Black Ops for a couple levels on Veteran, and I didn't feel challenged at all. When you die of like two shots and there is absolutely no room to move to a more tactical position, the only tactic is to memorize where the enemies are and in longer firefights just sticking to cover to take a shot or two every now and then.
I think this thread should be titled more in the way of "Last game you played that truly tested your skill" or somethinglikethat. In that case I'd say Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages' final boss, wearing the Cursed Ring (an item that halves your sword damage and doubles the damage you take). I've played that game a million times, so it only took like 5 tries, but was still pretty hard, compared to what I've been playing more recently.
And if you want a game where you truly can feel your skills grow, try Super Meat Boy.