Poll: Suicide

Recommended Videos

Koroviev

New member
Oct 3, 2010
1,599
0
0
I think such people are either immature or ignorant. Actual suicidal ideation is a serious symptom of severe psychological distress. If a person states or suggests that he is contemplating suicide, who am I to make the judgement that he is being untruthful? Such a sentiment is subjective. Short of reading the person's mind, I cannot know if the subjective statement is really true or false. The reason underlying such feelings is irrelevant. Whatever the case may be, the person in question feels that he is suffering and, moreover, does not have the resources to cope with the perceived pain. To mock such a person betrays either profound immaturity manifested by a lack of empathy or ignorance with respect to the nature of subjective claims and mental illness.
 

Ampersand

New member
May 1, 2010
736
0
0
Elcarsh said:
Ampersand said:
I look at people who kill themselves the same way I look at murderers. They don't care who they hurt and just want to take the cowards way out. In addition to that they throw away the only life they've got and everything they could have been just because it's sometimes difficult, there's no defending that.
Oh yay, another one who doesn't have the faintest idea what true depression is.

Allow me to make an analogy.

Suppose that we have a soldier, fighting a war against the odds. In the end, he's out of ammo and his sword is broken. There is literally nothing he can seriously do to keep fighting. Is he a coward for lowering his arms and taking the killing blow willingly?

That's what it's like to be clinically depressed. You have no hope that you'll get out of it, you've got no fight left in you, so you can decide to just end it. Life is an army that you cannot hope to fight, you've got nothing left, all you can do is quit. Doesn't make you a coward. If anything, it makes you a pragmatist. If there is nothing but suffering to life, then choosing life isn't logical.
You should be really impressed with yourself, I can count on one hand how many people there are who have actually made me angry and you're very close to making the cut.

Your soldier metaphor is a very good one. If you're on a battlefield with no bullets and a broken sword that doesn't give you the right to stop fighting, you've got teeth, you've got nails you've got blood running through you're veins and if there is anyone in the world that means even the tiniest little bit to you then you will use every little bit of it to bite and scratch and claw you're way out of whatever dark place you've dug yourself into, because you owe it to them if not yourself.

I've known depression, I've been there and I've been there for good friends who have known it too. I'd charge unarmed against the armies of hell for them and I'd expect nothing less from anyone else.
 

Baradiel

New member
Mar 4, 2009
1,077
0
0
I have seriously considered suicide, but not because I'm "depressed".

Let me try and explain: (These are all my own opinions. I am not trying to convince anyone else)

I am incredibly philosophical. I have already concluded that there is no God worth worshipping. If there is one he is not omnipotent as well as benevolent. I have considered what the world will be like in a century, and it is bleak. Mankind is only steering itself into oblivion.

What will I do with my life? Nothing important. Even if I became Primeminister, it wouldn't matter in the extreme long run. I could develop a cure for AIDs or cancer, but it wouldn't matter. Some of ailment would appear, possibly worse because of our overuse of medicines.

Basically, I have contemplated suicide because I don't see the point in living. Nothing particularly bad has happened to me, and I'm not depressed in the normal sense. I just don't see why I should suffer and drag myself through the natural span of my life, doing a pointless job simply to pay bills and keep wheels turning, only to die eventually.

If I don't get into university, and I don't find something else to apply myself to, I will probably kill myself, simply because I don't see why not...
 

AMAZED

New member
Dec 6, 2010
170
0
0
Aurora Firestorm said:
AMAZED said:
Suicide is a cowardly despicable action. In killing yourself you are abandoning your family and friends, you buck up and work through it. This isn't me talking out of my ass, I attended a conference where a team of people who had been through hard times came to talk to a school about suicide. Every one of them had a story and all of them were horribly tragic, one man even owns a gun that he originally bought to kill himself with but he got help and now he is married and has an incredible life.
"Buck up" is one of the worst things you can say to someone who is really depressed. "Hey, clearly this is your own darn fault, now pick yourself up and go on because you're choosing to feel this crappy!"

When the brain chemistry says you're depressed, oftentimes you need external help to fix it. Blaming someone's bad situation on themselves is a great way to look like a dick and make nothing better.
I didn't mean you should say that to them I simply meant they need to get past it, I in no way meant to imply that it is their fault although in hindsight it does look that way, I apologize if I offended you. The point I wished to make was that suicide is a selfish act you can talk to people and get help the way the guy I mentioned did.
 

holy_secret

New member
Nov 2, 2009
703
0
0
Daystar Clarion said:
Some people commit suicide for completely justifiable reasons, other people kill themselves because they're too cowardly to work out their problems the hard way.

As with any group of people, there are extemes on both sides.
No reason is justifiable enough for suicide to be okay.
 

Soods

New member
Jan 6, 2010
608
0
0
Off course I do. They're dead, so it's less harm done than mocking living people. But most people seem to have some kind of "respect" for the dead and go mad if you make fun of the dead around them. :(

Not all suicides are funny, but there are quite a lot of funny ones aswell.
 

Baradiel

New member
Mar 4, 2009
1,077
0
0
holy_secret said:
Daystar Clarion said:
Some people commit suicide for completely justifiable reasons, other people kill themselves because they're too cowardly to work out their problems the hard way.

As with any group of people, there are extemes on both sides.
No reason is justifiable enough for suicide to be okay.
What if your family and friends all died in a massive fire which destroyed everything you owned. You were also paralysed in the fire.

You have LITERALLY nothing left. Are you telling me if your lost EVERYTHING all at once you would not kill yourself?
 

Vredesbyrd67

New member
Apr 20, 2009
238
0
0
Oh, Nancy, this is shaping up to be a controversial thread.

First of all, suicide is not something you joke about. There is no death more tragic than a slow one caused by one's own hand. Suicide isn't something people just "do" on a whim; it often comes after years of depression, self-deprecation and adversity. And suicidal people ARE depressed people. How the fuck else do you suppose a person can do something so incredibly against their strongest innate instincts?

Another important thing that needs to get across: suicide is something ANYONE is capable of. It's not just for cowards, it's the product of a number of conditions that can be present in ANYONE'S life.

Whether suicide is "selfish" or not is irrelevant. People who kill themselves believe a number of things about themselves and the world:

1. Life is nothing but pain.
2. Nobody cares about them. Nobody really loves them.
3. Things are never going to improve, no matter what they do.


They think these things because their cognitive processes are skewed, because the amount of negative or traumatic events they have experienced are so multitudinous they have learned to view the world in a way that isn't necessarily true. Whatever suffering a person's suicide may cause to their loved ones, it NEVER outweighs the suffering they have experienced or caused to themselves. Suicide as a "selfish" action is a concept enforced by Judeo-Christian dogma, because those who follow it believe the human body and soul is not "theirs", but that it belongs to God, and so they don't technically have ownership over themselves.

Suicide is a desperate attempt to escape a painful existence that doesn't feel like it's worth living. For a person to even consider suicide, they have to experience a tremendous amount of emotional pain over an extremely long period of time. Suicide doesn't happen to well-adjusted people, it happens to wounded people and those with poor coping skills (for fuck's sake, count yourself lucky that you learned them while growing up, because some weren't so lucky; and you do have to learn them- they aren't innate).

Another thing: you don't get a pass to mock suicidal people if you were once so yourself. If anything, that gives you less of an excuse to do so, and it shows that you're still not over your problems; if you feel the need to mock suicidals, or even the right, that is a very old defense mechanism called Projection, which is a product of repression, and it denotes that the person making light of suicide isn't a "former" suicidal; the conditions in their life that caused them to have drastic cognitions like the contemplation of suicide are still present.

The only thing I will concede to the above is that those who have never experienced depression at a suicidal level have less of a right to take it lightly than those who have, but only because they have no idea what the fuck they're talking about.

Lemme let you in on something about yourself you may not know: because you're a human, and because humans are social animals, you have instincts built into your psyche to keep the strongest members in, and the "weaker" ones out. It's the same principle that causes herds to leave their older, sicker, weaker ones to die; if you can't help yourself, the tribe doesn't care to help you. The problem is that the tribe itself more often than not creates the very problems that cause others to become potential "threats." The way this translates into the current topic is that the people who become suicidal are often victims of paternal, social, or economic torment.

You know that phrase "don't let yourself be a victim?" That rancid fart of a maxim is a starry-eyed, overoptimistic view of the world that seeks to inspire others to great achievements by making it seem like everyone is capable of having personalities like Ghandi, who himself "refused to be a victim". Not everyone has the same cognitive processes. Not everyone is fortunate with how their lives turn out (Ghandi himself had money, despite being a minority. He was a lawyer before he became a human rights activist). The sad truth is the only way to live your life is to do the best with what you have. That doesn't mean you shouldn't try; nothing is gained without great sacrifice. What I mean is that not everyone has a high success rate in the total amount of endeavors they seek to accomplish. Not everyone escapes persecution and abuse. NOT EVERYONE HAS THE SAME LIFE. Saying that someone with emotional imbalances deserves to be made fun of is a statement on a level of ignorance that frankly I find staggering.
 

Tulks

New member
Dec 30, 2010
317
0
0
Jonluw said:
I haven't mocked anyone who's suicidal in the sense that I've made fun of them for being suicidal, but I've joked with suicide, the same way that I joke with baby killing, racism and rape.

I'm allowed to joke about suicide though, since I was/am suicidal myself.
This and this.
To some extent I feel that joking about it, in the right way, keeps it in the open and stops things getting on top of me.
 

Baradiel

New member
Mar 4, 2009
1,077
0
0
Vredesbyrd67 said:
Oh, Nancy, this is shaping up to be a controversial thread.

First of all, suicide is not something you joke about. There is no death more tragic than a slow one caused by one's own hand. Suicide isn't something people just "do" on a whim; it often comes after years of depression, self-deprecation and adversity. And suicidal people ARE depressed people. How the fuck else do you suppose a person can do something so incredibly against their strongest innate instincts?

Another important thing that needs to get across: suicide is something ANYONE is capable of. It's not just for cowards, it's the product of a number of conditions that can be present in ANYONE'S life.

Whether suicide is "selfish" or not is irrelevant. People who kill themselves believe a number of things about themselves and the world:

1. Life is nothing but pain.
2. Nobody cares about them. Nobody really loves them.
3. Things are never going to improve, no matter what they do.


They think these things because their cognitive processes are skewed, because the amount of negative or traumatic events they have experienced are so multitudinous they have learned to view the world in a way that isn't necessarily true. Whatever suffering a person's suicide may cause to their loved ones, it NEVER outweighs the suffering they have experienced or caused to themselves. Suicide as a "selfish" action is a concept enforced by Judeo-Christian dogma, because those who follow it believe the human body and soul is not "theirs", but that it belongs to God.

Suicide is a desperate attempt to escape a painful existence that doesn't feel like it's worth living. For a person to even consider suicide, they have to experience a tremendous amount of emotional pain over an extremely long period of time. Suicide doesn't happen to well-adjusted people, it happens to wounded people and those with poor coping skills (for fuck's sake, count yourself lucky that you learned them while growing up, because some weren't so lucky; and you do have to learn them; they aren't innate).

Another thing: you don't get a pass to mock suicidal people if you were once so yourself. If anything, that gives you less of an excuse to do so, and it shows that you're still not over your problems; if you feel the need to mock suicidals, or even the right, that is a very old defense mechanism called Projection, which is a product of repression, and it denotes that the person making light of suicide isn't a "former" suicidal; the conditions in their life that caused them to have drastic cognitive thoughts like the contemplation of suicide are still present.

The only thing I will concede to the above is that those who have never experienced depression at a suicidal level have less of a right to take it lightly than those who have, but only because they have no idea what the fuck they're talking about.

Lemme let you in on something about yourself you may not know: because you're a human, and because humans are social animals, you have instincts built into your psyche to keep the strongest members out. It's the same principle that causes herds to leave their older, sicker, weaker ones to die; if you can't help yourself, the tribe doesn't care to help you. The problem is that the tribe itself more often than not creates the very problems that cause others to become potential "threats." The way this translates into the current topic is that the people who become suicidal are often victims of paternal, social, or economic torment.

You know that phrase "don't let yourself be a victim?" That rancid fart of a maxim is a starry-eyed, overoptimistic view of the world that seeks to inspire others to great achievements by making it seem like everyone is capable of having personalities like Ghandi, who himself "refused to be a victim". Not everyone has the same cognitive processes. Not everyone is fortunate with how their lives turn out (Ghandi himself had money, despite being a minority. He was a lawyer before he became a human rights activist). The sad truth is the only way to live your life is to do the best with what you have. That doesn't mean you shouldn't try; nothing is gained without great sacrifice. What I mean is that not everyone has a high success rate in the total amount of endeavors they seek to accomplish. Not everyone escapes persecution and abuse. NOT EVERYONE HAS THE SAME LIFE. Saying that someone with emotional imbalances deserves to be made fun of is a statement on a level of ignorance that frankly I find staggering.
This is probably one of the truest things I have ever read on the Escapist. I feel sick looking at the people who say "There is no reason someone should commit suicide.", and I feel sicker when I read people saying that it's right to laugh at them.
 

AnAngryMoose

New member
Nov 12, 2009
2,089
0
0
Vredesbyrd67 said:
Oh, Nancy, this is shaping up to be a controversial thread.

First of all, suicide is not something you joke about. There is no death more tragic than a slow one caused by one's own hand. Suicide isn't something people just "do" on a whim; it often comes after years of depression, self-deprecation and adversity. And suicidal people ARE depressed people. How the fuck else do you suppose a person can do something so incredibly against their strongest innate instincts?

Another important thing that needs to get across: suicide is something ANYONE is capable of. It's not just for cowards, it's the product of a number of conditions that can be present in ANYONE'S life.

Whether suicide is "selfish" or not is irrelevant. People who kill themselves believe a number of things about themselves and the world:

1. Life is nothing but pain.
2. Nobody cares about them. Nobody really loves them.
3. Things are never going to improve, no matter what they do.


They think these things because their cognitive processes are skewed, because the amount of negative or traumatic events they have experienced are so multitudinous they have learned to view the world in a way that isn't necessarily true. Whatever suffering a person's suicide may cause to their loved ones, it NEVER outweighs the suffering they have experienced or caused to themselves. Suicide as a "selfish" action is a concept enforced by Judeo-Christian dogma, because those who follow it believe the human body and soul is not "theirs", but that it belongs to God, and so they don't technically have ownership over themselves.

Suicide is a desperate attempt to escape a painful existence that doesn't feel like it's worth living. For a person to even consider suicide, they have to experience a tremendous amount of emotional pain over an extremely long period of time. Suicide doesn't happen to well-adjusted people, it happens to wounded people and those with poor coping skills (for fuck's sake, count yourself lucky that you learned them while growing up, because some weren't so lucky; and you do have to learn them- they aren't innate).

Another thing: you don't get a pass to mock suicidal people if you were once so yourself. If anything, that gives you less of an excuse to do so, and it shows that you're still not over your problems; if you feel the need to mock suicidals, or even the right, that is a very old defense mechanism called Projection, which is a product of repression, and it denotes that the person making light of suicide isn't a "former" suicidal; the conditions in their life that caused them to have drastic cognitions like the contemplation of suicide are still present.

The only thing I will concede to the above is that those who have never experienced depression at a suicidal level have less of a right to take it lightly than those who have, but only because they have no idea what the fuck they're talking about.

Lemme let you in on something about yourself you may not know: because you're a human, and because humans are social animals, you have instincts built into your psyche to keep the strongest members in, and the "weaker" ones out. It's the same principle that causes herds to leave their older, sicker, weaker ones to die; if you can't help yourself, the tribe doesn't care to help you. The problem is that the tribe itself more often than not creates the very problems that cause others to become potential "threats." The way this translates into the current topic is that the people who become suicidal are often victims of paternal, social, or economic torment.

You know that phrase "don't let yourself be a victim?" That rancid fart of a maxim is a starry-eyed, overoptimistic view of the world that seeks to inspire others to great achievements by making it seem like everyone is capable of having personalities like Ghandi, who himself "refused to be a victim". Not everyone has the same cognitive processes. Not everyone is fortunate with how their lives turn out (Ghandi himself had money, despite being a minority. He was a lawyer before he became a human rights activist). The sad truth is the only way to live your life is to do the best with what you have. That doesn't mean you shouldn't try; nothing is gained without great sacrifice. What I mean is that not everyone has a high success rate in the total amount of endeavors they seek to accomplish. Not everyone escapes persecution and abuse. NOT EVERYONE HAS THE SAME LIFE. Saying that someone with emotional imbalances deserves to be made fun of is a statement on a level of ignorance that frankly I find staggering.
Thank you for summing up what I could not. You can't judge someone's reason for suicide by your own standards and then mock the person for it. To you it may not seem like a big deal, but it could be for them. Just because you've had a shit life, were suicidal or experienced someone close to you commit suicide does not give you any right in the slightest to mock suicide.
 

KalosCast

New member
Dec 11, 2010
470
0
0
ITT: A whole lot of insultingly bad armchair psychology.

For the record, one can't simply "get over" clinical depression. Telling people who suffer from depression to just get over it is like telling someone with a missing leg to just walk it off. Depression resulting from trauma or tragedy will be gotten over with time or counseling, yes, but that's a completely different beast.

Suicide is, more often than not, a cry for help or an act of desperation for people who don't see any other way out. The last thing these people need is to be mocked for it.
 

AnAngryMoose

New member
Nov 12, 2009
2,089
0
0
Soods said:
Off course I do. They're dead, so it's less harm done than mocking living people. But most people seem to have some kind of "respect" for the dead and go mad if you make fun of the dead around them. :(

Not all suicides are funny, but there are quite a lot of funny ones aswell.
You're ignorance is fucking stagger. There's no such thing as a "funny" suicide. Have someone you care about kill themselves and then see if it's worth laughing about.
 

gibboss28

New member
Feb 2, 2008
1,715
0
0
ooo this topic, what fun

Regarding jokes about suicide this quote sums it up:

John Marcone said:
Icehearted said:
On the internet they sometimes mockingly call it "heroics"
No. The meme is "an hero". Knowyourmeme [http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/an-hero].
Anyway, people mock suicide for the same reason they mock absolutely everything else in the world.
Why the fuck not?
Now That's that out of the way

To those who keep saying that only really depressed people commit suicide, sorry but that is a load of shit. I know people who have offed themselves because the dice didn't roll the way they wanted it to, so to speak. There are those who kill themselves because they are cowards and they can't live with the fuck ups they have made.
 

Exocet

Pandamonium is at hand
Dec 3, 2008
726
0
0
Daystar Clarion said:
Novs said:
Cool story bro.

except I didn't say depressed people were cowards.

I said some people commit suicide because it's the easy way out.

Suicidal =/= depressed

I never quite understood that statement,how is facing your own mortality the easy way out?
What makes solving your problems,whatever they might be,harder then facing every memory you have ever had,good and bad,and taking them all away from yourselves.And to top it all off,depending on how you did it,you might actually see yourself slowly drift away from life.


OT:I can laugh at a joke made at the expense of suicide,but I don't make fun of individual people that commit suicide.THe main difference for me being that one is a fact of life,one that cannot be stopped,and the other a tragedy that could have been avoided.
 

natster43

New member
Jul 10, 2009
2,459
0
0
Yes I do mock people who want to commit suicide, because I feel it is the pussy's way out. There are so many better alternatives to it, and if someone actually thinks it is the only thing the can do they are wrong and need to get help. I have had suicidal thoughts before,back in the harsh time known as middle school, when I was bullied, depressed and treated like shit by a lot of people. I don't care what you are going through, suicide is not the answer. There are people who are going through a lot worse in the world. Life will get better for them, they just need to stick around long enough for it to get better and not give up.
 

AnAngryMoose

New member
Nov 12, 2009
2,089
0
0
blakfayt said:
I say let'em kill themselves, A) the world has a population problem to begin with and B) some guys are gonna do it, whether they're mocked or not, I see no reason to make fun of someone in that horrible of a situation, but I see no reason to defend them either. I also think talking jumpers off buildings is silly though, for every guy who kills himself (at least in america) there is one more job, 3 more meals a day, and a new home (possibly) for someone who actually wants to live. Now if they're depressed, try therapy first, but if that fails, let them die. Same thing with old people and terminal illnesses, I can't fathom why someone with something like Huntington's or near death cancer would want to live in all that pain.
I can't even fucking consider you to be a human being. So someone's suffering is good because it benefits society? A society which, more than likely, rejected the person because of their mental instability. You are a fucking disgusting person.
 

StBishop

New member
Sep 22, 2009
3,251
0
0
As a general rule, I think it's abhorrent to joke about or mock suicidal people or suicide.

Then there's the "Oh golly gee, Mary-lou broke up with me and my daddy yelled at me a little because my report card had a D on it :'( Better end it all!" that happens a fair bit too much in teens.

That shit pisses me off, a) because I had a mate try to kill him self, and it's not cool to use a serious issue to seek attention; and b) because I had a mate talk about it for about 3 years on and off whenever the spot light wasn't on him, it's fucking frustrating, the first 12 times or so you take it seriously but then it get's old and you realise they love being dramatic.

AnAngryMoose said:
blakfayt said:
I say let'em kill themselves, A) the world has a population problem to begin with and B) some guys are gonna do it, whether they're mocked or not, I see no reason to make fun of someone in that horrible of a situation, but I see no reason to defend them either. I also think talking jumpers off buildings is silly though, for every guy who kills himself (at least in america) there is one more job, 3 more meals a day, and a new home (possibly) for someone who actually wants to live. Now if they're depressed, try therapy first, but if that fails, let them die. Same thing with old people and terminal illnesses, I can't fathom why someone with something like Huntington's or near death cancer would want to live in all that pain.
I can't even fucking consider you to be a human being. So someone's suffering is good because it benefits society? A society which, more than likely, rejected the person because of their mental instability. You are a fucking disgusting person.
Although I agree with your position, it's not necessary to resort to personal attacks.