@CA: But you can admit that some roles have far more power to change the course of a game than others, am I right? An Arbiter dramatically killing themselves and another has far more immediate impact than a Medic who may or may not be saving a life each time.
If it helps, don't consider it a classification of the roles themselves. Rather, it's just a power interlock. If they ask a spy question, commit an arbiter kill, or make a priest revival, then they are simply unable to use any of those powers again. If they use one, then they lose the ability to use any of the three.
This also helps to control the class. Initially, there is a 5/6 chance that the Wild card can make an action this cycle. However, if they become the spy and ask a question, the entire dynamic of the class is immediately reduced. Now, there is only a 1/3 chance that they will have a role. Additionally, the impact of this role is not felt as heavily by the entire playing field.
Basically, if a Wild Card is lucky and decides to be hasty, then they are rewarded with a short term blessing followed by a quick dive into relative irrelevance. If they are patient, then they can save the power for a time when it will be more useful...however, there is no real way to be sure that they will ever actually gain the ability that they want.
Does that make sense? I'm not really proofing myself since my attention is split.
If it helps, don't consider it a classification of the roles themselves. Rather, it's just a power interlock. If they ask a spy question, commit an arbiter kill, or make a priest revival, then they are simply unable to use any of those powers again. If they use one, then they lose the ability to use any of the three.
This also helps to control the class. Initially, there is a 5/6 chance that the Wild card can make an action this cycle. However, if they become the spy and ask a question, the entire dynamic of the class is immediately reduced. Now, there is only a 1/3 chance that they will have a role. Additionally, the impact of this role is not felt as heavily by the entire playing field.
Basically, if a Wild Card is lucky and decides to be hasty, then they are rewarded with a short term blessing followed by a quick dive into relative irrelevance. If they are patient, then they can save the power for a time when it will be more useful...however, there is no real way to be sure that they will ever actually gain the ability that they want.
Does that make sense? I'm not really proofing myself since my attention is split.