My god, this is insane. The amount of people shouting "fat ***** needs to shut up and die" has subsided, but the thread has somehow managed to
deteriorate. Christ.
Jumplion. I wasn't offended by your big post of examples of why men have contributed more to the world than women, because it was so full of nonsense. The major reason why there are so few famous women in history is that a little thing called "sexism" existed, and the number of women who were actually
allowed to do stuff like be educated and not sit around sewing or something was significantly lower than it is today. And the rest of your post was simply not true. They weren't allowed to fight in wars, and your personal experience with doctors and drivers means fuck all, when there's a hell of a lot of women who are doctors, drivers, and plenty of men who are nurses, and whiney-ass backseat drivers.
And then there's the fact that, even if the hypothetical situation were to arrise that men contributed more to the world than women, what the hell does that even matter? Does having a common factor with someone famous suddenly make you worth more than someone who doesn't?
Ooh, ooh, here's a fun thought. Guess what else 99% of the people you listed were? White! That means white people are better than black people, because white people contributed more to society. No, no, lets ignore the fact that white people had a massive head start in terms of civilisation, your logic
must be right!
For the robots of the internet, that was sarcasm. I was using sarcasm to make a point.
Everything else I wanted to say was basically summed up here:
Alex.P said:
McEwan is committing a pretty classic issue-blogger mistake there: taking some random example of a widespread phenomenon and raging against it like it's something special and extreme.
The princess trope in general is definitely... problematic. It's led to a whole host of works where the main female presence is depersonalized. When the woman could be easily replaced with a pile of treasure or a docile farm animal, it's hard to argue that some "objectification" isn't happening.
While the "fattening up" mechanic is novel/kinky/creepy, Fat Princess is pretty much just another free-the-princess narrative, just like many Disney movies and Mario games.
That doesn't mean it should get a free pass on all counts. But it's stupid to hurl a mountain of insults its way like it's the worst game since Custer's Revenge. It's not. I think it's obvious -- hell, even self-evident that it's not.
You can see McEwan stretching really hard to make it out to be a truly heinous, out-there kind of thing. It rings hollow. Especially since her primary accusation -- that the game is trying to depict fat people as ugly and "human garbage" -- doesn't really stick all too well. It's just something she manufactured based on her assumption that the game must be outstandingly vile rather than a mostly-typical pop-culture depiction of princesses and the obese.
... Which isn't to say that mostly-typical pop-culture depictions of princess and the obese can't be problematic. Just that it's ridiculous to attack each one individually rather than (semi-calmly) looking at why all of them together are problematic when taken as a single, culture-defining whole.
More people need to be this.
I would like to add, tho', that the whole reason that blogger was getting pissed was that the Fat Princess thing was offering up this morbidly obese woman as a figure of fun. Which it is. She was also annoyed that a lot of people think the concept of the game is hilarious. Which they do.
I'd also appreciate it if the people equating the word "feminist" with "feminazi psycho *****" would kindly stop. The two are different, and you're helping nobody by being so silly.
The majority of this thread has been filled with nonsense from people who read as far as "chubby chick hates on a game" and started firing up their death-threats and repressed sexism as soon as they realised that other people were doing the same. I haven't seen such horrible examples of humanity in months, so excuse me if I'm a little too shocked to properly convey my sheer disgust. I've had to revert to "cheerful mocking" because if I were to try and utilise any of my hatred for these silly, silly people, it would probably result in my failure to properly control my rage, and my subsequent ban.
Now, if you'll all excuse me, I need to go repeatedly punch something until I either run out of anger or my fist starts to bleed. I do hope I reach a pillow before I find a wall or a sibling or something.