And now to give back some stuff instead of just posting my own story. I can be a bit negative and just watched a bit of Yahtzee, so excuse me if it's a bit stingy and wordy, don't take it to heart - tho that's most likely to occur anyway.
If you don't want my feedback on your stuff for whatever reason, just skip it. I thought that was the point of this thread.
Taipan700 said:
Sounds like a basic premise for an action anime. I think it could be popular in Japan seeing as Christianity in every shape in form is something exotic and interesting. If you're serious about it, maybe try to include multiple biblical references. Bonus points if they make sense, if not people will try to make sense of them. That's how part of NGE worked.
It doesn't "wow" me at that point tho, but that could change by revealing exactly how things went wrong, if it's an innovative new scenario and not just "humans are stupid and destroyed everything, now the guardian angels have to save the last few so we can start from scratch".
Attributes like "the strongest of her kind" are dangerous because they don't leave much room for characterization and development of abilities which make up a good chunk of the exciting scenes of action anime. Just make sure it's not a Sue.
Daystar Clarion said:
My favourite is Amaya, an Immortal
When in doubt, take the name and translate it in a different language. Maybe try to avoid Latin or Greek if you use "common" words or words that directly root in those languages. For example, Immortal is already derived from the Latin "mortalis", or everybody already knows what "pyro" means. I'm not from an English speaking country, but I think "Tephra" on the other hand is a Greek word not very known (it's "ash").
The "dark past" backstory for both giving the character and motivation and "freeing" them from people that would stand in their adventure is pretty much standard by now, but it'll do the trick.
From the concept, I don't see any differences from humans, think whether you really need a new race, and if you do, try to give them unique features to separate them from others - both real, existing ones and fantasy races. There are already enough drunken bearded midgets pretending to be dwarves.
Be careful not to create a Mary Sue, I'd recommend taking the Litmus test. "Immortals" sound pretty much overpowered. If there's one thing young authors can learn from video games, even if they're not highly sophisticated in general design, is balance. Unless your character is fighting against another Immortal, they're most likely going to have a huge advantage. Rapid healing? Shrugging off spears to the gut? Inherent skills of past Immortals? She could be a hidden master of everything before the story really started, that doesn't leave a lot of skill development. In my opinion the best kinds of heroes are those who attempt to climb their way from the dirt to the top and then - depending on your story - either succeed or fail. Her personality also reminds me a bit of an author avatar. The type of personality a lot of people have who decide to sit down and create their own world and characters they're more comfortable with than the world they exist in. That was a bit of the whole point behind the Matrix, too. Neo is basically a Sue born from the mind of a hacker. He is the idealized version in the mind of a guy who writes a lot of programs on a computer. With Neo, his ability means "true" power in his world. It's fantasy, it's kick-ass, he's a super hero he could never be in his reality.
Charisma said:
Can't really say much about this one since we got a setting, but no plot. Five teenagers doesn't exactly sound like a very varied cast, but due to the lack of information it would be too early to speak of characterization as your weak point.
Let me remind you tho that "magic as status quo" is pretty much the point of the part of the Harry Potter verse most of the characters spend their time in - the part that's hidden from muggles. Extending the horizon of stories, there are lots and lots of video games in the fantasy where magic is the status quo as well. You could make it more interesting tho by not simply saying "this toaster runs on magic", but by coming up with a coherent magic system and developing new technology, uses and items around it. If you haven't done already, a bit difficult for me to read that out.
"Religion is Evil" and roughly one "magical element" per Pokémon type doesn't exactly sound fresh either. But maybe you can come up with new and unique combinations or new magic elements altogether. If the story didn't sound so serious I'd suggest taking the item to your left and slapping "-mancy" at the end of it. A wizard commanding an army of pencils sounds stupid, but a wizard controlling the shape and "molecular order" of carbon, ranging from graphite used in pencils to diamonds, suddenly doesn't sound so stupid at all.
Just make sure it's not a cliched "three noobs save the world within a month" story.
Serenegoose said:
You'd think humans and fae would have more contact if they hunt the same "prey". Lots'a'questions I have (that's a good sign, shows interest; sorry if I mix up some names):
- What's the difference between humans and fae besides difference in territory (and I suppose the fae can work magic while humans cannot and the main character lived up with humans, hence they only now realize magic exists)? Are they vastly different in culture and appearance or are faeries the local "slender humans with weird ears pretending to be elves"? Seeing as they can have sex and produce living children, they probably have a lot in common. I hope that doesn't make it boring.
- Your faeries sorta sound like elves in disguise. My question: In the original text you wrote "most of the Fae have no interest in humans", then in reply to an answer you say faeries see humans as cattle (what useful things do we produce? Certainly we can't produce anything beautiful, so the whole point of humans being the nerds of the animal kingdom surviving because of using tools i gone) and that they like having worshipers. Both sounds like good reason to make contact with humans one way or another. Seeing as they're not peaceful tree huggers either, surely they could have overrun the human world with magic before the invention of gunpowder and probably even now, too. Heck, humans were once run but a circle of half faeries (that was probably not very big or it couldn't have been overthrown that easily), surely full-fledged faeries know how to deal with them.
- If you're, as a half fae, physically indistinguishable from humans, what would you have to do except for not using flashy magic to hide yourself? Surely a civilization who just caught up to gunpower doesn't have the means to analyze a complete body composition throughout.
- You mentioned the city in the beginning a lot, but hearing about a story all about running away from stuff trying to kill you, I'd imagine she would leave a big city immediately and find shelter in some remote city where guards and bounty hunters are uncommon and the uneducated villagers can't tell a human apart from a half-fae.
- if half fae are the ideal servants, what's hindering the fae from breeding them? Would be much more convenient and easy to train, right? Seeing as there are "natural" half fae, I suppose humans aren't completely ugly in the eyes of fae either. Combine that with slavery and you have a harem full of breeding-machines. Now that's a concept of human cattle I can understand.
- what's your magic concept? Or is it just a colorful light show with which you can have awesome battles?
(sorry if I couldn't include answers being posted after my first post, I started writing this one immediately afterwards)