The Atrocities of Your National Heritage... This is a Fun Thread! :D

Recommended Videos

Ninjamedic

New member
Dec 8, 2009
2,569
0
0
Helmholtz Watson said:
As I said before, I'm not referring to the current splinter groups that are just cop killers, I'm talking about people like Bobby Sands.
He killed innocent people and was arrested for it. He chose to go on a hunger strike and starved to death thinking he could shame Thatcher. There is nothing he did that was morally justified.

Matthew94 said:
Well I disagree with you fully. I have no sympathy for the IRA of that era, they were terrorists, plain and simple.

Like I said to another person, the border is not far from no matter where you are and the republic is 5x bigger than the north. They can go south if they want to be free from the UK.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/march/9/newsid_2516000/2516477.stm

Even before Sands died the people voted to stay part of the UK so the IRA weren't fighting "for the people" or anything like that.

The only time I think you could fairly be on the side of the IRA is pre-partition when the UK ruled the whole island.
This basically.

I'd like to add that given the South's track record so far, you could argue the North has done a far better job of looking out for the welfare of its citizens.
 

geK0

New member
Jun 24, 2011
1,846
0
0
Irish: The whole Catholic vs Protestant thing got way out of hand

English: They were dicks to pretty much every country they ever colonized, plus the whole 100 year war thing against France was completely uncalled for.

Italian: Rome is in Italy; need I say more?

Canadian: We burned down the white house bitches!
 

Colour Scientist

Troll the Respawn, Jeremy!
Jul 15, 2009
4,722
0
0
Hazy992 said:
Nuh-uh! Triple stamp, no erasies, touch blue make it true!
Lalalalala, I can't hear you.

Well George Bush Sr. threw up on the prime minister of Japan and Prince Sebastian of Luxembourg was born. I win :D
Nu-aw! I was there for that too. I experienced more of the nineties than you, thus I am the champion of the nineties. Except for 1990 but that doesn't count either.
 

Helmholtz Watson

New member
Nov 7, 2011
2,497
0
0
Ninjamedic said:
Helmholtz Watson said:
As I said before, I'm not referring to the current splinter groups that are just cop killers, I'm talking about people like Bobby Sands.
He killed innocent people and was arrested for it. He chose to go on a hunger strike and starved to death thinking he could shame Thatcher. There is nothing he did that was morally justified.
Who did he kill? Wikipedia seems to have missed that part.
 

Hazy992

Why does this place still exist
Aug 1, 2010
5,265
0
0
Colour-Scientist said:
Hazy992 said:
Nuh-uh! Triple stamp, no erasies, touch blue make it true!
Lalalalala, I can't hear you.

Well George Bush Sr. threw up on the prime minister of Japan and Prince Sebastian of Luxembourg was born. I win :D
Nu-aw! I was there for that too. I experienced more of the nineties than you, thus I am the champion of the nineties. Except for 1990 but that doesn't count either.
Well ok then, but I think we can both agree that people born after 95 don't count either :D
 

DirtyJunkieScum

New member
Feb 5, 2012
308
0
0
Helmholtz Watson said:
Never claimed that everybody that doesn't like the IRA are Ultser loyalist, just that I'm as sympathetic to their cause as I am to southern states in the US that wanted to form the Confederacy.
Are you talking about Loyalist Paramilitaries here or just people who live in Northern Ireland who want to remain part of the UK?

Matthew94 said:
Like I said, the IRA were terrorists who committed horrible acts that the majority did not even agree with.

Also, peaceful means worked much better than fighting. If you look at NI now, much more progress has been made when they sat down and talked.
On that note:

These kind of arguments take me back to uni in 97 (in Manchester, a year after the bombing no less). There was a guy in my flat who had a friend from Belfast, not an active catholic but of catholic extraction and one day after the pub we'd got back and a foreign student (I'll let you guess where he was from, although in his defence he was young and drunk) decided to start spouting off to this guy about how great the IRA were for fighting for blah, blah blah, and dear god did the room turn blue. Complete silence in the flat for a good couple of minutes while he berated the ever loving shit out of him (Well, mainly the IRA and paramilitaries in general).
And while I do feel very bad about the fact that this Irish guy had had his entire childhood and young adult life marred by sectarian violence and fear of both the people who were claiming to be fighting for him as well as the Loyalist paramilitaries who were actually less likely to give him a beating if only by virtue of finding it harder to get to Unionist areas and the security services and government who, at best, weren't particularly friendly, it gave me great pleasure (even if I do feel a bit ashamed about it for the aboce reasons) to see him verbally tear this ignorant little twat a new arsehole and give him a lesson in not vomiting out garbage about shit he knows nothing about.
 

Ninjamedic

New member
Dec 8, 2009
2,569
0
0
Helmholtz Watson said:
Who did he kill? Wikipedia seems to have missed that part.
Okay, you shouldn't trust Wikipedia fully on a matter like this. Too much revisionism.

Whenever IRA members were arrested, the main argument they made was that they were "political prisoners" and that they should be treated like prisoners of war. The reason for that was they knew what they did (as he was arrested and repeatedly caught with weapons as Matthew said) so they tried to justify themselves ideologically instead.
 

Tropicaz

New member
Aug 7, 2012
311
0
0
Well i'm half english, and they have been absolute arseholes for most of history, commited many atrocities. Quarter Kenyan, they've had a few fights, there was the whole mau mau uprising in the 50s which had a load of atrocities on both the side of Kenya and England. Plenty of torture and killing. And my last quarter is german, and we'll noto get into that.
 

Helmholtz Watson

New member
Nov 7, 2011
2,497
0
0
Ninjamedic said:
Helmholtz Watson said:
Who did he kill? Wikipedia seems to have missed that part.
Okay, you shouldn't trust Wikipedia fully on a matter like this. Too much revisionism.

Whenever IRA members were arrested, the main argument they made was that they were "political prisoners" and that they should be treated like prisoners of war. The reason for that was they knew what they did (as he was arrested and repeatedly caught with weapons as Matthew said) so they tried to justify themselves ideologically instead.
....ok. I didn't ask you about what they called themselves in prison, I asked you who he murdered. Who did Bobby Sands murder?

DirtyJunkieScum said:
Are you talking about Loyalist Paramilitaries here or just people who live in Northern Ireland who want to remain part of the UK?
More towards the paramilitaries, but towards NI to a lesser extent as well.

Matthew94 said:
Helmholtz Watson said:
Matthew94 said:
So how does that make the IRA of that time any better?

He was still arrested multiple times with possession of weapons and was implicated in a gun fight as well form what I've seen. Hardly a poster child for freedom.
Why not, its not as if violence hasn't been used to fight for independence before. The history of my own country is proof of that.
And Ghandi got independence for India through peaceful means decades before. You cannot compare the independence of the USA which happened 300 years prior to the IRA in The Troubles.
And decades ago, Israel has had to use violence to perserve their independence. As I said before, people have had to use means other than peaceful one in order to have independence.

Matthew94 said:
Helmholtz Watson said:
Matthew94 said:
Helmholtz Watson said:
Matthew94 said:
Like I said to another person, the border is not far from no matter where you are and the republic is 5x bigger than the north. They can go south if they want to be free from the UK.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/march/9/newsid_2516000/2516477.stm

Even before Sands died the people voted to stay part of the UK so the IRA weren't fighting "for the people" or anything like that.

The only time I think you could fairly be on the side of the IRA is pre-partition when the UK ruled the whole island.
You'll forgive me if I have as much sympathy for Ulster Loyalist as I do for people who wanted to succeed from the Union and join the Confederacy.
You really don't know what you're on about do you? Not everyone who doesn't like/support the IRA is automatically a loyalist and goes marching in parades you know.

Stop bringing up loyalists as they have no bearing on the IRA of the 70s and 80's.
Never claimed that everybody that doesn't like the IRA are Ultser loyalist, just that I'm as sympathetic to their cause as I am to southern states in the US that wanted to form the Confederacy.
So you hate the people fighting to be free from the USA but approve of them in Ireland. Dat logic.
I hate people who are fighting to keep slavery a part of their economy.

Matthew94 said:
Anyway, you've yet to say why you actually approve of the IRA in the troubles other than "i <3 Bobby Sands". Like I said, there is a nation 5x bigger than NI just a few miles away that they could go to if they really cared.

Like I said, the IRA were terrorists who committed horrible acts that the majority did not even agree with.

Also, peaceful means worked much better than fighting. If you look at NI now, much more progress has been made when they sat down and talked.
As I said before, while I would agree that the current splinter groups are violent people who should be arrested, I don't feel the same way about the IRA of the past.

I like that the IRA sought to help contribute to the creation of a united Ireland.
 

Matt King

New member
Mar 15, 2010
551
0
0
England, like fuck do i need to even list them, at the moment we're mostly decended from normans, saxons, romans and vikings and they are pretty much all douchers also the whole "enslave the entire world thing" was pretty bad aswell
 

DirtyJunkieScum

New member
Feb 5, 2012
308
0
0
Helmholtz Watson said:
DirtyJunkieScum said:
Are you talking about Loyalist Paramilitaries here or just people who live in Northern Ireland who want to remain part of the UK?
More towards the paramilitaries, but towards NI to a lesser extent as well.
The paramilitaries I can well understand, but you oppose the right of the majority to choose their government?



All those people in the red (and past blue) areas can go fuck themselves yeah?
 

Commissar Sae

New member
Nov 13, 2009
983
0
0
Hmmm, well the residential schools and japanese internment camps were pretty bad. The chinese head tax was also quite shameful.
cathou said:
Well, two things come right away in my mind for Canada, but technically it was the British army that did it

Acadian deportation where the British army cleansed the French from maritime provinces
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsion_of_the_Acadians

And the hand out of contaminated blankets by Amherst to natives, hoping to give them small pox. It's one of the first bacteriological warfare event in history. It wasn't that successful but the intent was there.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffery_Amherst,_1st_Baron_Amherst
Well, there was also the residential schools, the Japanese internment and the Chinese head tax. Those are all 100% Canadian horrors.
 

Ninjamedic

New member
Dec 8, 2009
2,569
0
0
Helmholtz Watson said:
Ninjamedic said:
Helmholtz Watson said:
Who did he kill? Wikipedia seems to have missed that part.
Okay, you shouldn't trust Wikipedia fully on a matter like this. Too much revisionism.

Whenever IRA members were arrested, the main argument they made was that they were "political prisoners" and that they should be treated like prisoners of war. The reason for that was they knew what they did (as he was arrested and repeatedly caught with weapons as Matthew said) so they tried to justify themselves ideologically instead.
....ok. I didn't ask you about what they called themselves in prison, I asked you who he murdered. Who did Bobby Sands murder?
He was caught trying to flee after a gun battle with the RUC, leaving two wounded behind. They also found a revolver used in the battle in a car he used.

Again, he was a member of an organization directly responsible for killing innocents, considering it collateral in "the war against the Brits". Give that he was fighting the police there, was arrested multiple times in connection to bombings and stood up for said terrorist organization in prison, do you think he was innocent?
 

Tropicaz

New member
Aug 7, 2012
311
0
0
Matthew94 said:
Tropicaz said:
Well i'm half english, and they have been absolute arseholes for most of history, commited many atrocities. Quarter Kenyan, they've had a few fights, there was the whole mau mau uprising in the 50s which had a load of atrocities on both the side of Kenya and England. Plenty of torture and killing. And my last quarter is german, and we'll noto get into that.
By any chance were you born and raised in North America?
No. England. Mother's side moved from Kenya when she was 16ish and my German grandad came over here as a PoW and met my gran after, so the familys been rooted in england since 1940s/1970s
 

Aerosteam

Get out while you still can
Sep 22, 2011
4,267
0
0
Haggis is our traditional desert because it's made up of leftovers!