UPDATED!!!! Is she being selfish to want a baby??

Recommended Videos

Gudrests

New member
Mar 29, 2010
1,204
0
0
I can easlyy see him dumping her if she gets pregnant and find out she did this on purpose
 

Kelthurin

New member
Jun 18, 2009
204
0
0
Cyberwulf said:
He's in college and not ready to have a baby, according to everyone here. He should be using condoms, no matter what other birth control is being used.

You don't seem to realise that it isn't possible to control another human being, unless you're seriously fucked up and abusive. You can only control yourself, your own body and its own emissions and doings. Don't want kids? YOU use birth control. You can't rely on someone else to do it for you. Sure, you can scream and roar and leave forever if you end up with a baby anyway, and if someone deceives you that's perfectly understandable. But there's no escaping the fact that you could've done something to prevent it and didn't, because it was too much of a hassle, or killing the romance, or whatever.
Looking much less like a raving feminist now. Good. I'm glad.

Now who was talking about controlling another human being? I mentioned trust, not control. But that was in the bit you didn't quote, obviously.

If you were talking about a fairly new relationship, I would agree wholeheartedly on the condom thing. And yes, he probably should use one. Given that the girlfriend isn't at all trustworthy.
There is no denying that the bloke is a moron for sleeping with her when he knows that she unprotected, either.
However. I can't agree with you until you finally admit that the girl is being a right **** for doing this. So I guess we'll have a few rides on this merry-go-round of quoting still, eh?
 

Cyberwulf

New member
Sep 24, 2008
23
0
0
But many pills are actually spermacide AKA they kill the sperm as they come in
Hahaha NO.

So you are saying that we should assume that every woman who comes along is an axe crazy ***** who is immediately trying to trap you by tricking you into knocking her up?
I'm saying that if you personally don't want children, then YOU PERSONALLY are responsible for making sure that doesn't happen. It boggles my mind that people don't understand that this applies to men as well as women.

Kelthurin - I don't use that word. It's misogynistic.
 

CD-R

New member
Mar 1, 2009
1,355
0
0
Tell the guy what shes planning to do. Stop reading the Escapist and go do that.
 

SenseOfTumour

New member
Jul 11, 2008
4,514
0
0
Here's a test for her to try...

he needs to set the alarm to go off at least 4 times each night, and when it does, she needs to get up, slam one of her nipples in a drawer, burn £100, and smear jam and dribble all over one her favorite treasured possessions.

After a week ask her if she still wants a baby.

Essentially tho, I'm with everyone else, she's destroying the relationship for a baby, and she needs to know that she may end up a single mother over this, and not to expect any sympathy as she caused the break up, and he doesn't deserve the responsibility of a child he didn't want and may grow to resent instead of love.

A baby should always be a well thought out, careful decision agreed by TWO people ready to handle a lifetime of responsibility.

Honestly, a lot of people think they want a puppy, until it shits in their shoes, pisses over every piece of carpet in the house and chews up everything you've ever owned.

What you think you want and reality are quite different.
 

Kelthurin

New member
Jun 18, 2009
204
0
0
Cyberwulf said:
But many pills are actually spermacide AKA they kill the sperm as they come in
Hahaha NO.

So you are saying that we should assume that every woman who comes along is an axe crazy ***** who is immediately trying to trap you by tricking you into knocking her up?
I'm saying that if you personally don't want children, then YOU PERSONALLY are responsible for making sure that doesn't happen. It boggles my mind that people don't understand that this applies to men as well as women.

Kelthurin - I don't use that word. It's misogynistic.
So use another word. Don't worry, I won't feel offended if you don't use language as strong as I do. Really, worry not Miss.
 

GrimHeaper

New member
Jun 1, 2010
1,012
0
0
Technology is advancing so don't you worry your little wittle head about condoms.
Soon there will be a pill for men as well.
In certain countries this would get this woman executed.
 

R Man

New member
Dec 19, 2007
149
0
0
Cyberwulf said:
I'm saying that if you personally don't want children, then YOU PERSONALLY are responsible for making sure that doesn't happen. It boggles my mind that people don't understand that this applies to men as well as women.

Kelthurin - I don't use that word. It's misogynistic.
And yet, somehow she doesn't have to be responsible for essentially defrauding him. As already noted the decision to use a condom could easily be a joint decision based on trust. In which case he has been responsible via reaching an agreement with his significant other. If she decides to go off the pill without telling him she is violating that agreement and is therefore responsible as its her decision that leads to pregnancy (if indeed it does happen).

Women are also responsible, and since she is the one who made the decision (without consultation with her boyfriend). You can't absolve her of that responsibility.
 

omega 616

Elite Member
May 1, 2009
5,883
1
43
DemonicVixen said:
Your probably going to hate me for this, yay for internet anonymity.

She sounds like an immature, slightly short sighted *****, shes thinking "I will get preggo then he will have to stay with me", he's more likely to walk away 'cos she deceived him and all of a sudden it's "oh shit, I'm a dad".

If she was mature she would sit down and talk it out with an open mind, not a "I must convince him to be a dad" mind set. It will mean they can stay together and if he wants a baby aswell, then where is the problem in waiting?

It is just so illogical to do this.

It also means the next time she gets proper time to herself is when shes about 36! 'cos it's not fair to have a baby then dump it on her mum, so she can carry on being a twenty year old (enjoying life etc)
 

00slash00

New member
Dec 29, 2009
2,321
0
0
DemonicVixen said:
*sigh*... My mate has just left, and im at a loss of what to say or do now so i'll ask you guys.

My mate is 19, same as me though will be turning 20 in December. She is in a long term relationship with a great guy, they've been together for 9months now and he's just turned 20 this month.
She came to me confused as she's decided she wants a baby and knew that i do also so thought i could help. Her partner is willing for kids as is mine, but, like mine, he wants to finish his Uni course and get a full time job. He told her he'd be happy if she fell pregnant, but scared at what it could do to them. She however already has it all planned out.
She's even more confused because he sleeps with her even when he knows she isnt protected, and isnt phased when she jokes on about might being pregnant.

Here is my dilemma...

She's on the combined pill, and has decided to stop taking it, and let nature take its course. He doesnt know about it and she doesnt want to tell him as she thinks he might leave her or reject any child that might come of it. Obviously she's asked me to keep it secret but i dont want to see him get hurt as a result of it. I love both of them like family, and i dont know what to do... Yes i can see she has it worked out in a way that would probably work for them both, but im not sure she realises the emotional and physical strain a baby will do to him during his last years of Uni...

Ive decided to ask you all this as i know there are adults and probably broody teens on here who can tell me what i should do, or at least persuade her she's being unreasonable and unfair to him at this time. Or maybe im just paranoid =/

EDIT: Failed to mention they're living together also in a 2 bed flat.
i mean no disrespect because i know your close with her, but shes acting like an idiot. first of all, shes way too young. most people that young arent mature enough to raise a child and even if she is, having a kid will prevent her from experiencing a lot of things. add on to that the fact that financially, they would probably be completely fucked. also, the fact that shes tricking him into getting her pregnant makes her seem really untrustworthy. i know im being kinda harsh on her but from the outside looking in, this is how the situation is coming off, to me.
 

Talshere

New member
Jan 27, 2010
1,063
0
0
SenseOfTumour said:
Here's a test for her to try...

he needs to set the alarm to go off at least 4 times each night, and when it does, she needs to get up, slam one of her nipples in a drawer, burn £100, and smear jam and dribble all over one her favorite treasured possessions.

After a week ask her if she still wants a baby.

Essentially tho, I'm with everyone else, she's destroying the relationship for a baby, and she needs to know that she may end up a single mother over this, and not to expect any sympathy as she caused the break up, and he doesn't deserve the responsibility of a child he didn't want and may grow to resent instead of love.

A baby should always be a well thought out, careful decision agreed by TWO people ready to handle a lifetime of responsibility.

Honestly, a lot of people think they want a puppy, until it shits in their shoes, pisses over every piece of carpet in the house and chews up everything you've ever owned.

What you think you want and reality are quite different.

Pfft, if a puppy does that your training it wrong :p
 

2fish

New member
Sep 10, 2008
1,930
0
0
I request that we stop the argument over how to stop making a child and focus on the topic of trust here. She is going off the pill with the goal of getting pregnant without telling the guy.

Yes if he is not using a condom he is stupid, but she is planning this with the goal of getting pregnant and perhaps trying to guilt him into keeping the kid she wants.

That is dirty and low. What is she going to do next poke holes in all of his condoms?
 

Master_of_Oldskool

New member
Sep 5, 2008
699
0
0
Is she selfish to want a baby? No. Is she selfish to potentially force one on him without his knowledge? Yes. My advice is to tell her to tell him. If she refuses, then it's your call whether or not to tell him yourself.
 

GrimHeaper

New member
Jun 1, 2010
1,012
0
0
2fish said:
I request that we stop the argument over how to stop making a child and focus on the topic of trust here. She is going off the pill with the goal of getting pregnant without telling the guy.

Yes if he is not using a condom he is stupid, but she is planning this with the goal of getting pregnant and perhaps trying to guilt him into keeping the kid she wants.

That is dirty and low. What is she going to do next poke holes in all of his condoms?
I wouldn't see it beyond her.
 

Impluse_101

New member
Jun 25, 2009
1,415
0
0
Kefo said:
1) shes 19, I dont care how mature people think you are you are not ready for a baby at that age

2) they have been together for 9 months. The hell is wrong with people? I waited a year before I moved in with my current gf/fiancee and waited another year before asking her to marry me. Make sure there is a relationship before bringing a baby into a split home.

3) she sounds like a conniving ***** and if she is not telling her partner that she is off the pill to trick him into getting her pregnant she needs her ovaries cut out with a rusted spoon
1 and 2 I agree with.

3 also until you hit cutting that organ out.

The guy who she's with should just dump her right then and there if he knew any better.
I mean it like this: If your both young and consider having a child. Your not ready, cause A. YOUR YOUNG. I believe in the waiting till after marrige to have a kid, which it can varey depending on a lot of things that I won't list in this post.

9 months.....like having to wait for giving birth to a kid? I'll tell you right now, having a kid is SERIOUS BUSINESS. You have you raise it, nurture it, love it, all that great stuff that should happen in life but doesn't to the few couples out there who do it wrong.

I'll quote Yahtzee for this final sentence to my post. "I think all the ovaries around the world should inflate out of the woman and fly up in the sky like a red balloon parade". This however being said with the rule that it only affects these stupid people around the world.

Reguardless, this is just only my opinion. One in a million all that jazz.
 

KezzieZ

New member
Sep 20, 2010
90
0
0
Well, I think it's past selfish for your friend not to tell her boyfriend something like that. Babies take a lot of responsibility and, almost if not just as importantly, resources- like time and money, which most 20 year olds don't have nearly enough of.

If she wants a baby so badly, then she needs to talk it over with him instead of skirting around the issue until it happens without his consent. That's not fair to him and I wouldn't be surprised if it caused at least some sort of rift in their relationship, especially considering he gave a perfectly reasonable explanation for not wanting a child at this stage.
 

kikon9

New member
Aug 11, 2010
935
0
0
The Scythian said:
Nothing? Her life, her choice.
It's also his life. She is destroying his hopes of going to college by not telling him that she isn't on birth control. Safe sex is a two way street.
 

astrav1

New member
Jul 6, 2009
986
0
0
Tirunus said:
She is tossing his future away so she can get what she wants, and after giving her a reason why they should not and she still continues to attempt to get pregnant.

So she is lying and destroying his future so she can have a baby? Yaaaaah I have a feeling this will not end well.
Of course it won't end well. We just have to wait for natural selection and the invisible hand to run its course.