What game do I hate?
Alright, people are going to attack me for this and call me a troll, and I don't care. I am answering this question honestly.
Ready? Knights of the Old Republic.
I will admit a few concessions. The writing is good (what I got through it. Also I harbor a deep resentment against the game because I have used all three versions, and the only one that wasn't too buggy to play was my least favorite way of playing the game, and that was the original X-box.
That being said, it was a stupidly unbalanced game that had an ungodly number of bugs. Even the working X-box version crashed more times in two weeks than I care to remember. That, and I have some issues with the role playing. First is character creation. You start off with three possible classes, but there is only one obvious choice. If you don't take it, you essentially cripple yourself and your party for part of the game. Then, that first class you take gets replaced really quickly with a Jedi class. And you will most likely pick the melee combat Jedi because the game demands that you take your first six levels at least as a melee character, so it is your best way of cutting your losses. Then there are the moral choices, which generally allow for no flexibility because the evil choices are so hilariously evil that no one would pick them in reality. Alternatively, there are the Jedi morality questions which make no sense to anyone who is not a fan of Star Wars, so players are punished for not being fans of the universe. Finally, there is the lack of rewards for good characters. I had a good game and an evil game going simultaneously. The good character was pretty much living broke no matter what he did and was only taking very specific quests and missing out on XP in favor of staying good. The evil character was rolling in money and XP, which was eventually balanced by a glitch on the Jedi planet that would cause the game to crash. It was all so broken and unplayable. I am told that the plot makes up for it, but I honestly just kept on getting infuriated until I finally realized that plot can really be that worth it, especially to a person who already thinks that George Lucas was over celebrated before the 21st century.