Infernai said:
Contrary to popular belief, i don't believe Sexuality is 'encoded' or we are 'born with it'...I'm sorry, but to me, that is right up there with saying 'god made me do it'. Sexuality, atleast to me, is determined by a persons nurture as is most other things. Ok, naturally SOME things are passed through genetics, not denying that, but Sexuality ain't one of them. Sexuality is a choice, that simple.
This kinda reminds me of when people say Evolution is a belief system.
It's really odd to me.
Because how would folks feel if someone just said one day "Arithmetic is a belief system, frankly I don't think division works that way."
Wouldn't that come across as odd? Kinda stupid, maybe crazy?
There is so little evidence to support sexuality as a choice that I find it so odd that anyone could say it without following it up with "I've done absolutely no research into the topic."
At least then I can read it and say "Well I suppose if I was just randomly making up theories about how the world works based on my own personal feelings I could come up with crazier things to say."
Otherwise I'm just left stumped.
There is a really long blurb about why this is a dangerous view even if you personally don't use it to hurt people, but this question gets brought up on these forums about once every three days so its obviously a waste of time.
Apparently nobody has access to case studies anymore. If only there was some interconnected series of computers where this sort of thing could be answered.
I'll see if Al Gore is around for some help on the problem.
Cpt.Muddles said:
Arguably. I've studied psychology and I think that the nurture part of the whole Nature vs Nurture (DNA vs Upbringing) is just as influential. What really isn't our choice is that we're made to reproduce with the other sex and have children - doesn't mean everyone wants to do that. Again, Nature vs Nurture.
When did you study it? I finished up my Degree 2 years ago, there was 0 debate on the topic.
Nature decides the range of possible outcomes for any one person, nurture decides where on that range you end up.
So any person is genetically limited to a certain range of heights (for instance) and their nutrition will decide where in that range of heights they end up.
Sexuality appears to be something that, at best, is decided during gestation. So nurture does the work while in the womb, but nature takes over once ejected. Too many genetic markers and actions early on in life correlate with sexuality post puberty for it to be influenced strongly (or in any statistically significant way) by post-birth nurture.
Unless we are also going to argue that the direction your hair twists is nurture as well?
I probably shouldn't say argue, I don't really plan to come back to the thread

. There will be a new one on the same subject in 48 hours anyways.