I couldn't really say, as I rarely judge endings that strongly. I'm of a "the journey is more important than the destination" sort of person. It's not to say that I think the ending is unimportant, just that I can forgive a poor ending if the rest of the game/story was good.
Take Bioshock, for example. Sure it had a crap ending, but the ending wasn't the point of the game. The main point of the game is done being presented to you before you even get to the final sequence of the game, so while the ending is fairly weak, I'm able to forgive a little because it's that first 90% of the game from which I get my enjoyment.
Take Bioshock, for example. Sure it had a crap ending, but the ending wasn't the point of the game. The main point of the game is done being presented to you before you even get to the final sequence of the game, so while the ending is fairly weak, I'm able to forgive a little because it's that first 90% of the game from which I get my enjoyment.