70% of people in England hate their health care!

Recommended Videos

Dale Cooper

New member
Apr 12, 2009
465
0
0
Treblaine said:
Dale Cooper said:
England's health care is bad for the taxes we pay, BUT nowhere need as bad as it is in America.

If I'm sick and I have no money I can still see a Doctor.

If I break my leg it's treated free.

If I need an operation, it's done free.

So I'm happy enough.
Emergency medical care (like broken legs, cuts, etc) are free in America. Every hospital receives federal funding on the remit that they cannot turn away or refuse to treat any injured patients who arrive. (Anyway, emergency medical care is cheap, it is serious surgery and treatment for chronic illnesses that cost a lot.)

The problem in America is the "grey areas". People who are not in poverty (they have medical cover provided by govt) yet are not rich enough for full health coverage so are stuck in a middle ground.

That is basically what Obama is trying to do, fill in the gaps between America's already extensive socialised healthcare system and the private healthcare. By European standards it is not a very socialised system at all.
That's interesting to know, I remember watching a Morgan Spurlock thing about health care in America and for low income families it looked really tough.

I hope Obama is able to make the changes, it might be because I get free health care but I do feel that everyone should be entitled to be healithy.
 
Apr 17, 2009
1,751
0
0
Crowser said:
Just heard this on Fox. Apparently 70% of people living in England, Australia, France, Germany and New Zealand want to, and I quote "Dismantle their health care system and start anew." Yes, I know this is bullshit but I'm curious how people of these nations feel about our media's portrayal of them, especially with all this health care hoo ha going on right now. Funny? Sad? Offensive? Also, do you know any people from any of these countries that actually do want to "dismantle the health care system and start anew."?
I'm a Brit, and not only do I not dislike the NHS, but I have a parent who works for it. I think the people who got those alarming statistics probably only asked ten people. Tell you what, statistic makers, ask everyone in the UK what they think of the NHS, then tell me that 70% of people want to dismantle it. What's that? You can't? Oh, what a surprise
 

Sebenko

New member
Dec 23, 2008
2,531
0
0
Silly America.

See mah money?

I'm gonna go have a heart attack. Oh look, I recovered thanks to the NHS
You go have a heart attack, you recover, but then have to live in poverty.

While I go do something fun, like throw a party.
Yeah, I think the NHS is great.
It might not be prefect, but who is? Besides Colombo.
 

AngloDoom

New member
Aug 2, 2008
2,461
0
0
Crowser said:
Just heard this on Fox. Apparently 70% of people living in England, Australia, France, Germany and New Zealand want to, and I quote "Dismantle their health care system and start anew." Yes, I know this is bullshit but I'm curious how people of these nations feel about our media's portrayal of them, especially with all this health care hoo ha going on right now. Funny? Sad? Offensive? Also, do you know any people from any of these countries that actually do want to "dismantle the health care system and start anew."?

I've never heard people really complain that much about the NHS. They always say things like "the waiting-times are bad" but then they always go "but at leas it's free and effective." Maybe I just know that 30%, but I've never really heard many people say they want to scrap the current system in favour of a new one.

Just sounds like FOX are trying to knock the wind out of the sails of people in America who may complain about the health-care by saying "but look at these other, poor countries."
 

Trivun

Stabat mater dolorosa
Dec 13, 2008
9,831
0
0
Crowser said:
Just heard this on Fox. Apparently 70% of people living in England, Australia, France, Germany and New Zealand want to, and I quote "Dismantle their health care system and start anew." Yes, I know this is bullshit but I'm curious how people of these nations feel about our media's portrayal of them, especially with all this health care hoo ha going on right now. Funny? Sad? Offensive? Also, do you know any people from any of these countries that actually do want to "dismantle the health care system and start anew."?
I am really annoyed at the way the US conservatives and all the rich people who don't want to pay more tax are going on about national healthcare like it's a bad thing. Fine I admit that here in Britain the NHS isn't perfect. We have dirty hospitals and high amounts of MRSA. You know why? Because Gordon Brown, our un-elected 'leader', cuts costs. Something that most likely will not happen under Obama. Brown steals the money under 'expenses claims'. Obama, as far as I'm aware, doesn't, since from what I know the US doesn't have any sort of system like what we have for politicians expenses. He wants nationalised healthcare to help people who can't afford medical insurance. And that's a good thing.

One of the biggest criticisms I have is that a group of conservatives against national healthcare recently released a video about a British woman who had cancer and was treated by the NHS. She then, in the video, apparently criticised the NHS and complained about the standards of UK hospitals. Couple of days later, that same woman and her daughter appeared on UK television. On the news. Saying that her comments were taken completely out of context and edited to make her appear against public healthcare. She also said that without national healthcare she would now be dead.

I am perfectly happy with healthcare in the UK right now. All we need to do is stop giving the government staff more money and actually pay the cleaning companies more and simply make our hospitals more hygenic. There needs to be a bit of a shakeup with certain hospitals where staff are reported as incompetent, and get more nursing staff in. There are problems, I admit. But overall, the UK healthcare system is alright. And with a new government it will be even better. We just need to make a few changes, but I'd never go as far as to say it needs to be completely abandoned and started again.
 

Ghostkai

New member
Jun 14, 2008
1,170
0
0
Crowser said:
Just heard this on Fox.
Stopped reading.

This is just that stupid campaign again to say "lol American's Health Care is fine kk". I think I saw a snippet of a feature (I think it was on Fox) where they went to the length of bashing all the Euro-Healthcare systems to try and instill confidence in their own system. Rather childish to be frank.
 

gh0ti

New member
Apr 10, 2008
251
0
0
WTF?

Never heard so much BS. It's political suicide in Britain to suggest taking apart the NHS, because people effing love it, regardless of its problems.

I find it offensive that the NHS is being dragged through the mud by American pundits (knowing some brilliant and hardworking people who work in healthcare), but the overriding sensation is one of pity and anger for the American people. Seriously, why aren't you guys more outraged that being the richest country in the world hasn't equated into having the highest standard of living in the world? By this measure the US has been in relative decline for over 60 years.

EDIT: I'm going for some foot surgery this afternoon. It took me a single week to get it looked at and then booked, and it's an extremely low priority procedure.
 

annoyinglizardvoice

New member
Apr 29, 2009
1,024
0
0
British here.
The NHS isn't perfect, but it's far better than the American way. The last time I had an op done, everyone was very helpful and profesional. I didn't feel corners were cut or masses of paperwork got in the way.
I have a few gripes with it, but they're small in comparison to what I would be if the system was entirely private.
 

Jupsto

New member
Feb 8, 2008
619
0
0
the statistics for england are pointless. here in england we hate and complain about everything. its not like America or china where they brain wash you with propaganda and you HAVE to love your government/country/leader. here everybody always hates the prime-minister just because hes the prime-minister. everyone criticizes the government, which the NHS (national health system) is a part of.
 

mayney93

New member
Aug 3, 2009
719
0
0
axia777 said:
mayney93 said:
I am british and without our NHS my grandparents generation in my family would not still be here because they have all suffered from either industrial disease, coal miners or they suffered from a form of cancer because of all the smoking, ask one of them if they h8 the nhs, they love it and the idea of it
Dear British People,

Please gather about 10,000 of said elderly people. Send your respected elders over to our nation. Please ask them to beat this wise and intelligent idea in the minds of our elderly and Baby Boomers as they are too ignorant and stupid to see the wisdom of it. Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,

Americans with Brains
finally an american that isnt inbred or a blonde plastic barbie
 

TelHybrid

New member
May 16, 2009
1,785
0
0
Branovices said:
Honestly 70% of the English probably hate or complain bitterly about 70% of everything. So that's not really a surprising statistic to me. (I kid!)
Hey I'm English, and to be honest that's rather accurate. We are a nation of complainers. XD
 

Fozzo

New member
Apr 15, 2009
31
0
0
Fox are peddling right-wing lies to you! I'm English and I think the NHS is one of the best ideas politicians have ever had. Of course there's issues with how it's being run (GPs divide funding how they see fit. Big paychecks for them, fuck over the entire hospital they work in) but the idea is solid. We just need to improve the admin side of it so they don't think that sacking 100,000 staff is a good way of sorting the costs out!
 

Treblaine

New member
Jul 25, 2008
8,682
0
0
Dale Cooper said:
Treblaine said:
Dale Cooper said:
England's health care is bad for the taxes we pay, BUT nowhere need as bad as it is in America.

If I'm sick and I have no money I can still see a Doctor.

If I break my leg it's treated free.

If I need an operation, it's done free.

So I'm happy enough.
Emergency medical care (like broken legs, cuts, etc) are free in America. Every hospital receives federal funding on the remit that they cannot turn away or refuse to treat any injured patients who arrive. (Anyway, emergency medical care is cheap, it is serious surgery and treatment for chronic illnesses that cost a lot.)

The problem in America is the "grey areas". People who are not in poverty (they have medical cover provided by govt) yet are not rich enough for full health coverage so are stuck in a middle ground.

That is basically what Obama is trying to do, fill in the gaps between America's already extensive socialised healthcare system and the private healthcare. By European standards it is not a very socialised system at all.
That's interesting to know, I remember watching a Morgan Spurlock thing about health care in America and for low income families it looked really tough.

I hope Obama is able to make the changes, it might be because I get free health care but I do feel that everyone should be entitled to be healithy.
Well it does create a kind of welfare trap at the moment. People don't want to work longer or go for promotions as they would actually end up with less coverage. Also, due to the nuances of perhaps supporting several children one may be earning enough to not be considered "in poverty" but with the several more mouths to feed and backs to clothe can effectively put them back into poverty. Systems like these are always flawed as it is too hard to measure where poverty ends and self-sustainability begins.

I support Obama for wanting to close this gap and I think Republicans would support it too if they knew what he was doing and were not so suspicious he was trying to undercut their current liberal healthcare system (I mean liberal in the non-political, literal sense).

I have never lived in America but people seem to have a lot of misconceptions and assumptions about US healthcare and you wonder where they get their ideas from.

Perhaps it is partially down to the likes of Michael Moore as in Bowling for Columbine he accosted a Canadian walking out of the Emergency Care section of a hospital with bandage around his head, Moore makes the point that this guy did not have to pay for this treatment but implied that the same would not be true south of the border.

You really have to be careful with these Moore and Spurlock types. They are not journalists, they have no dedication to impartiality, accuracy and have absolutely no qualms with being incredibly misleading with the facts. It would be a stretch to call their work "Propaganda" as they are not working for any government or political entity (merely profit) though their methods are virtually identical.

BTW, I lol'd in Supersize Me where literally the FIRST BURGER he ate on his mission he felt sick and almost puked. And he deliberately did not try ANY of the restaurant's healthier options, he rigged his "experiment" to get the results he wanted by trying to be as unhealthy as possible yet somehow blame the restaurant for that!

Incidentally, if Michael Moore is wondering why the life expectancy is lower in USA than the "wonderful socialist utopia" of Cuba, perhaps he should not be looking at America's healthcare but America's lifestyle which he HIMSELF is a perfect example of: Obesity. Something I have in common but I blame no one but myself.

For America (and increasingly Britain) the population eats too much, drinks too much, still smokes too much, no where near enough exercise and not enough vegetables or other essential nutrients of a balanced diet. There was an article in this week's New Scientist magazine as in the US the detecting, treating and curing of diseases in very high in America, their health system in general is doing great. The problem is SO MANY people are getting diseases linked to lifestyles of excess and sloth that the odds are tipped against them. This is to spite insurance premium "incentives" to lead a healthier lifestyle, people would rather pay more, eat more and exercise less. But perhaps that's democracy; people voting with their wallets.

Cuba is almost an example of the key to longevity not from their healthcare but their borderline-poverty. In another article of New Scientist (can't remember issue) it details how the single best way to increase life expectancy is to severely reduce calorie intake, basically live on the edge of a starvation diet. The way scientist think this works is the low calories force the body to lower its metabolism, similar to a tortoise (famously long living creatures), basically like running an engine at lower RPM there is less strain to cause cancers, heart failure etc.
Considering how even today Cuba has strict food rationing and generally high cost of food goods it is a large scale example of how if we go by overall life expectancy, then a life on the edge of poverty is preferable.
 

Generic_Dave

Prelate Invigilator
Jul 15, 2009
619
0
0
There was a survey done in England recently that said nearly 98% of people were satisified with their health care in the NHS. Okay, now by numbers that 2% is still 6 million people over 10 years or some such...but I can name many companies that would kill for a 98% satisfaction record. It's unheard of...sure people still get a raw deal, have to wait a while or end up in a less than stellar hospital, but you can't argue with 98%...unless you're Fox News that is...

I just don't see why you can't have private and public carriers...most national systems have an overlaid private network for those who want better service and it still usually works out cheaper for positive results...my health-care plan works out about E50 a month...and it's taken out before tax so it works out about 80% of that, say E40 a month...which works out at less than E500 a year...I dunno how much of my taxes go on healthcare, but if they didn't take it for that it'd go somewhere else...so I wouldn't be paying less taxes, it'd just go on something less worthy...
 

ProfessorLayton

Elite Member
Nov 6, 2008
7,452
0
41
So... you're believing what Fox News says, right? Fox News is putting up an inflated number of people who didn't like the health care that Fox News is against... I see nothing new here.
 

TallanKhan

New member
Aug 13, 2009
790
0
0
I live in England and yes while alot of people arent happy with the healthcare system there are very few who would be in favour of dismantling it. Apart from the fact that most British people will always complain about anything that isnt perfect given the chance, the truth is while they dont like the current system there isnt a better one.
 

Spirultima

New member
Jul 25, 2008
1,464
0
0
I love my healthcare system, and everyone i know either likes the fact they don't have to pay for it or they just don't care.

Also Fox news is biast and always supporting the republicans, i know that and im English, what does that say?