For a pilot it was good. It was good, but awkward. I felt like the three guys where reading from a piece of cardboard someone had held up in behind the camera, that they where just reading off what they had previously written before. Frankly I think that they need to set this up in the same way they do the Australian Gamer Podcast. In the AG podcast one of them (I have no idea who... Matt maybe) comes up with a few topics and then all three talk about them and provide their opinions. I think that this would make a much better format for the show. Coming up with your opinions on the spot and not reading them to us will make the show feel more natural and remove that awkward tension. It will also add the ever so enjoyable podcast antics to the show, something I feel it needs. It would also be better if the show would feature less skits. The MGS one was lame, the Halo one was alright but a little replayed and obvious and the Duke Nukem one, while funny showed about as much thought and planing in the actual skit. It was clear to me that the skits where time wasters, an attempt to lengthen the show. If you want to turn this into a series then you can't be coming up with things to lengthen the time. One or two skits in the show would be great but 9 is way to much.
But like I said it was good. I don't feel like my time was wasted.