Games that werent supposed to be scary the frightened the crap out of you.

[Jonny49]

The beginning to the first level in brothers in arms. You're plane crashes, your alone, you don't know where you are and you have no weapon. I felt like a zombie was going to jump out or something.

 

[Cmwissy]

Assassins creed, where you are left on the animus at the end of the game - all alone in that room, it was okay when the doctors were watching you as you 'slept' in there.

Feels really lonely.

 

[mariosuperlative]

When it comes to fear I'm the weakest guy around. Therefore I was scared of the sunken ship in Okami. I ventured forth down a corridor to have a massive ghost come right onto the front of the screen. It couldn't hurt you, but it still freaked me out. Later, you're jumping along floating wooden platforms on the top of the water and this massive green hand flies out of the water and starts trying to smash you to death. And finally, near the end, another big ghost flies to the front of the screen. This one doesn't hurt you either, but it does start biting rapidly, you slow down, you go into the next room, you turn round to make sure it's gone and you see it snapping ferociously zooming right at you. Thankfully it disappears after that...

 

[I Stomp on Kittens]

Tetris. One time I could've sworn they were forming a gun...

I think that happened to me once. Another time I made it say "DIE" and showed it to my friend.

That game tried to rape me...I will never be the same *runs away crying*


Any game were i'm walkin along and an enemy come up behind me and jumps on me (Batman:AA, FO3)

 

[Baby Eater]

mario 64. i was a little 6 year and i decided to do a certain water level.i was swimming around for awhile wondering what i was supposed to do.then: pink eel o.o. my dry cleaner was never more surprised/horrified and to this day i still stay on the surface of the water for like an hour before going down

 

[Dannyboy1186]

Fallout 3's vault with the drugs in the air scared me shitless, And im still jumpy in that game. Too many times ive turned around and...

Spoiler: Hey Good looking!

[img/] http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/fallout/images//thumb/c/c3/Deathclaw_(Attacking)_FO3.png/750px-Deathclaw_(Attacking)_FO3.png[/img]

And yes, I have yelled "baahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh" when that happens.

I dunno, even with all my awesome gear I always wound up jumping just a bit when I turned around to see a Deathclaw nomming on my ass. D: Or a ghoul for that matter. Didn't really surprise me when a super mutant to a sledge to me though. *shrug*

I agree with you there except I normally press the vats button only to discover a pouncing deathclaw right behind me when I was aiming for something else. But its more scarier for me if its in real time and I hear footsteps then theres something right behind me. But that mainly first person shooting games.

 

[Mr Companion]

Pikmin 2, the submerged castle. Those who have played will sympathise.

 

[Spitfire175]

Morrowind. The Dwemer ruins scared the crap out of me. And the ashlands. And some of the monsters.

 

[MrSnugglesworth]

Deathclaw.


Now you may think "Kill it" but it bugged, and the Deathclaw jumped into the sky, then landed on me, killing me.

First time I ever played Fallout 3 at a friends house.


*sigh*

 

[theSovietConnection]

Hmm scary when not ment to be scary... headshots I don't see coming from the side if they hit the 1st time I always jump a little,but scary in a scary game about the 80% of the time in Echo Nights: Beyond. (Shudders)

Oh god that game was always good for a scare. Which one did it for you? Mine was always

Spoiler

that fucking priest from the fisheries and the mine elevator, the way he'd shake the security camera if you moved it when he was around, and the way he'd block you from trying to run past him.

Oh yeah every time.

Spoiler

It didn't help that sometimes you could walk down corridors that are locked at the other end early on and come back and find the preist just popping up to screw with you once you clear the objective in the last area.

I didn't realize the black robes were apart of his uniform till I found his info thought he was a special demon/ghost sense he never stayed in one place.

I didn't have him pop up as often as I did one of the Russian astronauts. I don't know if this was a glitch on mine or what, he would just pop up and stand there, not doing anything. I couldn't talk to him, but he didn't affect my heart rate either.

 

[cainx10a]

Fallout 3's vault with the drugs in the air scared me shitless, And im still jumpy in that game. Too many times ive turned around and...

Meanwhile, in another vault...

'Gaaaary!'

First encounter with Gary was shocking. The following encounter with the other Gary(s) scary as hell.

 

[Milkatron]

I get really scared when travelling through Oblivion's caves, mines and forts. The first time Lucien Lachance from the Dark Brotherhood scared the crap out of me, too. I was too busy wondering why my character was waking up after only an hour's sleep, when the camera suddenly zoomed in on him, and I actually yelled.

Wasn't as bad as one time when Jauffre came up behind me to say something. I yelled and fell out of my chair. Caught me way off guard, which I guess is bad for a thief character.

 

[happysock]

Fear 2 *shakes head in dissapointment*

 

[matsugawa]

anyone ever played warhammer 40k : firewarrior for ps2? that game is scary

At first it seems bad enough early on when the chainsaw-wielding generals come running headlong at you from around a corner... then the space marines show up.

 

[Baby Eater]

Pikmin 2, the submerged castle. Those who have played will sympathise.

i feel for you mate. the trash monster with louie on it made my cousin fall out of his chair

 

[timmytom1]

Batman: Arkham Asylum. Those Scarecrow segments...yeck...

Spoiler

The boss fights were just flat-out bad, but the parts before them were just creepy. The voices in the room during the first one would have creeped me out more if I hadn't spent like 10 minutes looking for the Riddler challenge. Seeing the Scarecrow after I left the room was unexpected. I loved the flashback before the second one, that was paced perfectly. And I personally freaked out during the third when the game looked like it was glitching and restarting, then my thoughts went to "What's going on?" then to flat out "WTF" when I realized my controller didn't have a middle stick. but yeah, those were good.

You`ve almost perfectly summed up what i was going to say

 

[Mewick_Alex]

Halo.

*waves goodbye to street cred*

The flood showing up in level 6 really freaked me out. I didn't really have any prior knowledge of the game when I bought it and I was just expecting a very average run-and-gun shooter, so I wasn't expecting any of that creepy shit to start happening. Plus I have a thing about zombies, they're wierd.

 

[Maeshone]

Dunno if it really scared me, but it definately creeped me out...

In Final Fantasy VII when you've infiltrated the Shinra Corporations headquarters there's a part after you've escaped from the cells where you follow a trail of blood from Jenovas "cell" that leads upwards through the building. This combined with all the dead bodies that litter every floor and the disturbingly creepy music actually had me genuinely creeped out!

(And I played it the first time when I was 18!)

 

[UnkeptBiscuit]

Batman: Arkham Asylum. Those Scarecrow segments...yeck...

Spoiler

The boss fights were just flat-out bad, but the parts before them were just creepy. The voices in the room during the first one would have creeped me out more if I hadn't spent like 10 minutes looking for the Riddler challenge. Seeing the Scarecrow after I left the room was unexpected. I loved the flashback before the second one, that was paced perfectly. And I personally freaked out during the third when the game looked like it was glitching and restarting, then my thoughts went to "What's going on?" then to flat out "WTF" when I realized my controller didn't have a middle stick. but yeah, those were good.

You`ve almost perfectly summed up what i was going to say

I do that a lot.
EDIT: I guess I'm a ninja.

 

[Xanadeas]

Fallout 3's vault with the drugs in the air scared me shitless, And im still jumpy in that game. Too many times ive turned around and...

Spoiler: Hey Good looking!

[img/] http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/fallout/images//thumb/c/c3/Deathclaw_(Attacking)_FO3.png/750px-Deathclaw_(Attacking)_FO3.png[/img]

And yes, I have yelled "baahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh" when that happens.

I dunno, even with all my awesome gear I always wound up jumping just a bit when I turned around to see a Deathclaw nomming on my ass. D: Or a ghoul for that matter. Didn't really surprise me when a super mutant to a sledge to me though. *shrug*

When you get Charon, that feeling is gone
I have him equipped in decent Power Armor and Power Helmet. I'm a low level, so it's the best I can get for him so far. But, alas, we are still an awesome team

I never take any companions with me. D: I'd feel bad if they died.