Okay. I'm bracing myself. I'm probably going to regret saying this, but: Psychonauts. Hear me out: After searching and searching and searching, I finally found a copy which cost thirty-five dollars. May I just say that this is double what I payed for Beyond Good and Evil, which is an unbelievably fantastic game, and triple that of the original Jak and Daxter.
On to the game itself, the art style, voice acting, blah blah blah was good. I didn't fully understand the story; not being the type who scrounges for every available collectible, I didn't know the backstory of most of the characters, so the story didn't make sense to me. Mind, I haven't yet seen the final cutscene. I did technically "beat the game" in that I beat the final boss, but my game froze and now whenever I lose a life I don't respawn, though this may because I got a used copy.
Yes, the game was funny, but most of the humour was based on the obscurity and absurdity of the concept, and considering that Ben Croshaw kindly lists out most of the funny stuff and ruins the shock, I wasn't that entertained.
The gameplay wasn't terrible. The platforming was pretty good, but you could do most of it by summoning your thought bubble and slowing your fall so you can hit any platform with ultra-precision. Combat was just kind of weird. It was the Force Unleashed problem, in which I couldn't really feel that I was hitting the enemy. And I have since decided that I hate "Adventure Elements," which consist of talking to everyone until somebody says something plot-relevant, doing whatever they say, and then talking to everyone once again to see if anything changed.
Sorry about the long hate-speech. I just don't understand why this seems to keep topping lists of "Under-appreciated Masterpieces," or "Games that are Art."