Without reading the 8 pages of this entirely (pardon me if this is repetitive) it occurs to me that violent video games couldn't be responsible for this because his parents wouldn't let him have any. That is what ultimatly sparked this, is it not? He wanted to play Halo (which isn't even a realistically violent game), his parents said 'no' (and honestly if they said 'no' to that then they probably said no to most games). He bought a copy, this turned into an arguement, and it got violent.
Now personally, I do not know the choreography of what went down in the house. A lot of crucial details are missing from this, including how his parents behaved in general (not letting him have Halo 3 seems fairly oppressive from where I'm sitting) and it strikes me that they guy probably had problems to begin with, and this was simply a "last straw" kind
of thing.
It seems to me that the judge is out to make a point here too.
At any rate, instead of blaming the video games, I'd think it might occur to more people that the kid probably had some pent up rage, and no way to release it. If this was one of those "no violence for our kids" households and this was an extension of that policy, then they were probably asking for it.
I mean, growing up there were parents who wouldn't let their kids play with "GI Joe" or "The Thundercats" or watch the cartoon shows. Never mind run around with squirt guns (or regular 'clicker' guns and cap guns) playing army or whatever. Video games are not the only method of focusing some of those impulses (which are actually very normal, especially for dudes, it's how we're wired) but a modern one. I'd imagine if you really investigated the
kid wasn't able to do any of that stuff... and again we don't know what the parents were like.
The whole "video game addiction" thing seems like the result of a bad lawyer who couldn't come up with a decent defense, or for whatever reason had an agenda other than defending his client. I might personally see that as part of a defense, or a fallback, but not the crux of an entire defense.
>>>----Therumancer--->