It was beginning to get stale, but the stuff he's put out recently (past month or so) has been pretty good.
I missed how the earlier stuff was written from a review perspective as opposed to an angry rant. In later reviews, it seemed like Yahtzee was becoming less of a character and more of a caricature (like Maddox), almost as if he was caving into people's expectations of how his reviews should be.
I also liked how deadpan and nonchalant his tone used to be, it was very British.
Anyway, I don't think ZP has run its course. I'll continue to watch, as it is the highlight of my Wednesday afternoon.
So, I guess Response #2?