sigh.....
Brother, you can't just say "make me like anime" and expect someone to come out of nowhere with a series that is so good that it makes you have an epiphany. you have to find your niche. you've only seen the big name animes, but the better ones are actually lesser known, at least in my opinion.
Take me for example: I'm a guy who likes action. Naruto, Bleach, Immortal Reign, Veritas, One Piece, Air Gear, these aren't anything new to me. My sister is in to shojo stuff, like Fruits Basket and VB Rose. We both have our own opinions and neither of us can figure out why we like the mangas we do. I can't recomend any Manga or anime in particular, but I can recomend this: search around MangaFox. They're a great place with tons of entries, and you can read up on anything that looks interesting to you.
Also, and I just thought of this, Check out the mangas for the following: Shaman King, +Anima, and Immortal Reign. They are brilliant in their own right. Btw, I think you'll find that the manga is always better than the anime. DON'T WATCH THE ANIME FOR SHAMAN KING.
Edit: I think I remember this really weird OVA called Pale Cacoon? only saw it once, and it was bizzare. Check that out.