Poll: Looking for real advice not moral zealots

Recommended Videos

soren7550

Overly Proud New Yorker
Dec 18, 2008
5,477
0
0
I say only go for it if you truly think your future marriage won't suffer from it. If both the friend and the fiance are cool with it and you're alright with the idea, go ahead.

Just prepare yourself though.
 

VitalSigns

New member
May 20, 2009
835
0
0
Mimsofthedawg said:
VitalSigns said:
Mimsofthedawg said:
VitalSigns said:
I have been with my Fiancee for 2 and a half years, our mutual friend is coming up to stay the weekend and visit, our friend was talking to me in private and made a "joke" about a threesome. Girlfriend found out and to my surprise said she would be cool with it. So this should all be good right? The Catch: this other girl has expressed to me a few times that she has legitimate romantic feelings for me, and I once actually told her I had them back but I wasn't going to leave my Fiancee. I'm scared this could also complicate things, that being said both girls are stunningly attractive, smart, fun etc, and I want to do this pretty bad. Is it worth the risk of the complications to have a wicked and memorable night?

EDIT*** Clear up some things

-Me and my fiancee are very open minded.
-This is not something She is doing just cause she thinks i'd like it, we have talked about the idea of a threesome for a while now
-Other girl (the friend) said that any feelings she may have for me are under control and would not let this become a problem. (she could just be saying that however)
-I am confident in my sexual abilities and truly don't feel this would be either awkward, or laughable.
-Any guy with a libido would want this to happen.
God bless your fiance who's marrying a guy asking for advice on a gaming website... bahhahahhaha.
your right, I forgot all gamers were sexless socially awkward nerds who don't know the first thing about a women or how to please one. Your shitty thoughts probably come from having your head up your ass all the time.
hmmmm... you know, I never intended to dis gamers at all. I was more saying that I would figure you'd ask a question like this to a person you know... I'll correct my statement...

"... a guy asking for advice on an internet forum..."

There. :D
I wanted anonymous advice, people who don't know any of us, I find an outside opinion is better than an inside one in some cases. Plus this getting around our friends could potentially be bad. Sorry about the Head : Ass remark, I get defensive sometimes haha.
 

smithy1234

New member
Dec 12, 2008
1,218
0
0
"Do it do it do it!"

is what my primal man urge is saying to you

"My god you fool! You're willing to risk a loving marriage with an obviously kick ass woman considering she is open to the idea of a threesome??? CMON! Don't be a dumbass!"

is what my intellectual side is saying to you
 

Myself0101

New member
May 2, 2008
32
0
0
Personally I think you would be risking too much, I mean your fiancee is someone you obviously think you could spend your life with, whereas this other girl you simply have 'romantic feelings' for. Secondly, girls may claim to be open minded, but never are, or at least to the extent that they claim. Thirdly, don't you think this sounds like a million tv shows/movies where this would be a massive fuck up? Fourthly, you wouldn't enjoy it, that I can PROMISE you! You would spend the whole time worrying about what it might do to your current relationship and what if it sucked and then things are never the same? People genereally go into these things always thinking of best case scenarios, but in reality....those don't happen.

Good luck man, in the end it's up to you!

p.s. nice touch ask people on a gaming forum, the only girls we get are inflatable (I ain't talking about American girls either, more the plasticky ones.....on second thoughts that makes them sound more American...)

p.s. ignore the racism, i'm Scottish
 

kawligia

New member
Feb 24, 2009
779
0
0
Sex outside a relationship is very likely to cause problems, even when it's mutually agreed upon. There is absolutely no way to anticipate what kind of trust or jealousy issues will arise in YOU much less someone else.

The vast majority of people who try this come to regret it, but not all.

I would jump on it if I were not serious about the girl I was with. But if I was serious about her, there is no way I would roll the dice.
 

Uncompetative

New member
Jul 2, 2008
1,746
0
0
Cheeze_Pavilion said:
There's nothing so intolerant as an atheist who wants to be a fundamentalist.
There's nothing so amusing as an ignoramus who wants to be a philosopher.

Cut out the epigrams and you won't come across as quite so pretentious. I said what I said to the OP to mock him and his concept of marriage. I'd love to know if his fiancee was saving up for a big white wedding in a church. If only I could tip off their priest what a couple of fakes they were...

It really makes no difference whether you are experimenting with the oxymoron that is an Open Marriage, or failing miserably at monogamy during your Engagement, it is still a religious ceremony with legal after effects. It would really simplify matters if there was a Civil Union for Heterosexuals as there is for Homosexuals in the U.K. (that is, a non-religious monogamous legal union with all the benefits in Tax and Law), but as far as I know the powers that be denied us all this.

Take God out of the equation.

Give people the option to have a partner without having to lie their way through their oaths. After that I don't care what they get up to.

marriage + threesomes > marriage > threesome

broken engagement because of a bad three way >>> broken marriage because of a bad three way

If this is going to be a part of their future lives together, best to try it out now when the consequences are lower.
Your math is flawed... it should be:

man + woman + God = marriage

man + woman + woman = threesome


Note: how God chooses not to be present in the second equation.

VitalSigns said:
I love my fiancee with all my heart and you do not have the right to tell me that because we BOTH agreed that this something we wanted to try we don't love eachother. the 1600's were a long time ago.
Hmmm. You love your fiancee with all your heart, do you?

I doubt that. She should be more than enough for you...

The funny thing about all this is that I wouldn't recommend Marriage to anyone and don't ever intend to marry myself - more as a reaction to it being a religious union under God and me not believing than the potential restrictions of monogamy. I've never understood the whole psychology of this Bachelor Party/'Last night of freedom'/'Have sex with the stripper' thing that men do.

Trying it out now when the consequences are lower? Really, the OP should just quietly sit down with his girl and say:

"I think we should call off the Wedding given that we both want to fuck other people."

Just saying...
 

VitalSigns

New member
May 20, 2009
835
0
0
Uncompetative said:
Cheeze_Pavilion said:
There's nothing so intolerant as an atheist who wants to be a fundamentalist.
There's nothing so amusing as an ignoramus who wants to be a philosopher.

Cut out the epigrams and you won't come across as quite so pretentious. I said what I said to the OP to mock him and his concept of marriage. I'd love to know if his fiancee was saving up for a big white wedding in a church. If only I could tip off their priest what a couple of fakes they were...

It really makes no difference whether you are experimenting with the oxymoron that is an Open Marriage, or failing miserably at monogamy during your Engagement, it is still a religious ceremony with legal after effects. It would really simplify matters if there was a Civil Union for Heterosexuals as there is for Homosexuals in the U.K. (that is, a non-religious monogamous legal union with all the benefits in Tax and Law), but as far as I know the powers that be denied us all this.

Take God out of the equation.

Give people the option to have a partner without having to lie their way through their oaths. After that I don't care what they get up to.

marriage + threesomes > marriage > threesome

broken engagement because of a bad three way >>> broken marriage because of a bad three way

If this is going to be a part of their future lives together, best to try it out now when the consequences are lower.
Your math is flawed... it should be:

man + woman + God = marriage

man + woman + woman = threesome


Note: how God chooses not to be present in the second equation.

VitalSigns said:
I love my fiancee with all my heart and you do not have the right to tell me that because we BOTH agreed that this something we wanted to try we don't love eachother. the 1600's were a long time ago.
Hmmm. You love your fiancee with all your heart, do you?

I doubt that. She should be more than enough for you...

The funny thing about all this is that I wouldn't recommend Marriage to anyone and don't ever intend to marry myself - more as a reaction to it being a religious union under God and me not believing than the potential restrictions of monogamy. I've never understood the whole psychology of this Bachelor Party/'Last night of freedom'/'Have sex with the stripper' thing that men do.

Trying it out now when the consequences are lower? Really, the OP should just quietly sit down with his girl and say:

"I think we should call off the Wedding given that we both want to fuck other people."

Just saying...
I think your an idiot, who is trying to dictate what love is based on sex. We love eachother and I'm not sure what makes you think you have the right to decide whether thats true or not.
 

Shock and Awe

Winter is Coming
Sep 6, 2008
4,647
0
0
Thats hilarious, honestly bro, Im going to say just go with the flow, if they want to do it, go for it.
 

Beffudled Sheep

New member
Jan 23, 2009
2,029
0
0
Country
Texas
Its not as great as you might think, and trust me on that. I say don't do it, the risks far outweigh the benefits. If you and your fiance weren't getting married and were just going out then yes. But you are getting married and it will come back to haunt you some time down the road. Do what you want but I recommend that you don't do it.
 

Huggiesunrise

New member
Jun 9, 2009
6
0
0
If you make it down here to read this I commend you.. if this is a troll. Well done!


Sooner or later your going to have to stick to your own moral subtext on the issue. If you do this your taking steps away from a monogamous relationship and while your friend jokingly started it your half of the relationship is the initiator of this event. This means basically your obligated to be at the will of any similar desires your fiancée has now and in the future.

Polyamorus (POLY AMORY NOT POLY GAMY) activity is just that. You have a female friend with romantic notions towards you.. these are not controllable no emotions are editable.. you can suppress them you can even ignore them but the stress and pressure will always be there and this is 100% of a psychotherapists cause for existence is the ego A type forcing of emotions to or away from yourself unnaturally.

Also. Do not.. ever. take.. advice.. and act on it from peers. They aren't you.. you don't know how you feel and for lesser reasons it is a hit to you integrity to let anyone else to the driving.

Feeling nervous or weird about stuff like this is natural int hat new things always cause jitter especially if they are utterly alien so the social promoted norms. Bottom line, the honest acceptance or rejection of it will happen after this occurs, you'll know if your cut out for it or not.


More to the point and most importantly. even if it costs you everything you have the confidence in what you want will be solid afterward either way. Whether you like it or NOT odds are it needs to happen.
 

Trace2010

New member
Aug 10, 2008
1,019
0
0
If your girlfriend is bi, then this could be the start of a great many sexual adventures...just remember, turn-a-bout is fair play.

Personally, I would never want to share my wife with anyone...I'm just way to ##&^^ possessive.
 

Seventeen

New member
Jun 15, 2009
19
0
0
Hmm In the end, its very much up to you dude but some things to think about are:

1. You only live once and in my mind try to take every possibly good experience thats on offer.
2. Think about the mindset of the other girl, I'm sorry ladies but as much as guys can be pricks, women can play some pretty horrific mind games to get their own way.
3. Everything might be great at the idea stage but it can be alot different when in practice. Someone might suddenly change their mind, it could even be you and then things become sour.
4. Your girlfriend can get jealous either mid sex or sometime after about something simple like "the way you looked at her" or "you've never done that with me" etc and that starts a rift between the two of you.
5. Is it really worth it? Is it something you personally desperatly want or is it just a gimmicky kind of thing that your not really to arsed about. Would you still want one even if she was against the idea.
6. From my "experience" its happend after being drunk and it can become quite a funny, laughable scenario, even silly. Its still a threesome but its nothing like you'd see in a porn film. Granted this proably was just the drink that made mine go a bit comical.

At the end of the day. It's up to you. This probably isn't the question an internet forum holds the answers to. :p Talk it over with a mate who knows you both and can give you an informed external view on the situation. Though be prepared they may ask to join in haha