irishda said:
Take all that stuff he does, and now ask yourself: Why couldn't he do any of that with a gun?
Guns make explosions all the time in movies, and bullets are impossible to catch. The guy's lame because his place in a world with aliens and magic is kind of limited, but they can't change his M.O. because then the fanboys would be pissed off that the guy known for using a bow isn't using a bow.
I'm not 100% sure, so don't quote me, but I believe the answer to that question is that guns are noisy, a bow is slightly more versatile in range than a single gun is, and above all, you're in more control with a bow. I believe that is why Hawkeye uses a bow rather than guns. Not to mention the arrows are easier to clip add-ons to than bullets would be. He does use guns in the comics, and in the movie once or twice, but aside from Ultimate, he states he doesn't like to use the guns.
Syzygy23 said:
But the Team already HAS the Hulk, and he's the strongest there is, and Tony Stark brings the smarts, soooo.... Why is Hawkeye here? His only power is "Really good at archery". Wow, uh, that's... great... I guess? Here's the deal, though: The rest of the Avengers fight shit that can punch a bus through 3 skyscapers on a daily basis. The MINIMUM requirement for joining this team is that you be bullet proof. Are you bullet proof? No, wearing purple fish scales does not make you bullet proof, you'll still get bruised to hell and back, possibly die from internal bleeding.
Tony is smart, as we clearly saw in the movie, he's no tactician. The hulk isn't the brightest fighter either and would be more quick to just smash stuff. Yes he's Bruce, but as stated, Bruce even when in control is a bit more chaotic and wishing to rip limbs apart when he's the Hulk.
Not only is Hawkeye tactical with his shield training, through out the fight, he had the birds eye view of the battle field and gave information to his team mates. The other Avengers have no reason to be at that distance, but Hawkeye does. He's the sniper.
At the same time, you're argument of "They need this requirement" Can literally throw Batman out of the just league. There's no fucking "but" there, if what you say is true for the Avengers, then it's true for the Justice League as well. Batman may have the gadgets and tools and I do like him, but he's not god. The case in point is that he may be easy to take out, but he's doing a lot of damage and is actually assisting his team in several ways. And above that, isn't risking your life kind of the point of being an Avenger? No, the point of being a hero?