I'm not sure what the stereotype is, but now that I think about it I might qualify:
I'm indifferent to Halo.
I haven't played MW2 but I know enough about it to say that if I did I'd hate it.
I watch ZP religiously and usually agree to some extent with Yahtzee, though Saints Row 2 is putting that to the test.
I just played Portal, which may have turned me into a Valve fanboy, though HL is falling into the just alright category.
Looks like I'm getting there. Is there any sort of charter of right thinking I can study to hurry the process along?