Andy of Comix Inc said:
inb4 "Duke Nukem Forever" oh too late. Fucking idiots. Duke Nukem Forever was fine. Wasn't great, sure, and was it disappointing after 14 years, of fucking course it was. But no game for the past five years has truly been "great," except maybe Portal, and no game will ever be worth a 14 year wait, except maybe Half-Life 3. Duke Nukem Forever hate makes me sad to be a gamer, because it was a legitimately entertaining and light-hearted FPS in a sea of mediocre combat sims and deserved to be treated better than it treated. Actually, I'd almost go so far as to say it's probably one of the best games of 2011, for me.
So far... worst game... hmm... I'm going to go ahead and say Terraria. It probably isn't that bad, but the whole cult following the game has undeservedly amassed makes me mad. IT'S 2D MINECRAFT WITH AN ENDGAME. YOU JUST RUINED EVERYTHING THAT MADE MINECRAFT SPECIAL - FREEDOM, AND ENDLESS CREATIVITY. And for some reason you make it in complete pixel-art. Why? You wanna know WHY? Because Minecraft did it and you're trying to be Minecraft. Eurgh, I hated that game.
Are you for cereal?
DNF was a massacre that was 10 years past it's prime, it was awful. Limited weapons, weapons that suited the exact situation (about to fight a boss? Here is a rocket launcher! Do you need a shotgun? Well here you go!), annoying as fuck engine sounds, really annoying/boring one liners.
Terraria is nothing like minecraft, the only thing they have in common is you start off making a house or shelter of some kind, after that there is nothing a like.
Firstly, terraria is a game and minecraft is a building sim
not a game!. A game has goals set into it, beat the bosses/story/other people playing/whatever. A sim has no end, you could play minecraft for a billion hours and be no closer to the end, the same goes for train simulator, flight sims etc. You set your own goals in game but there is no winning it.
Oh sorry, you can craft in both games as well, although I would have to say the crafting in minecraft is crap (irony!), congrats you can make a pic axe with a bit of stone and some sticks but as far as I know you can't make your own potions etc. (I am not including mods in any of this 'cos you can mod anything to have anything)
I also have to mention infiniminer, the game with far too many "I"s in it ....
I think my choice for worstest game is obvious.