declared Non-Canon

[kahlzun]

every Stargate SG-1 series after the 8th. Just plain doesn't exist. Illusions from a heat-oppressed brain.

 

[MassiveGeek]

the pokemon games that came after the second one (excluding Fire Red,Leaf Green,Heart Gold and soul silver)

I would punch every person who say's that in the soul if I could because the pokemon games just keep improving in gameplay and pokemon design is only changing in style and is not getting worse or unoriginal.

Well, it is getting a ton more... silly.

Just imo.

 

[FoolKiller]

No. There are no movies or shows that I consider non-canon as there was only one Matrix movie

 

[Nazulu]

The last Metroid was Prime 3.

I'm fairly certain that the last one they made was Super Metroid.

Yeah, that's still my favourite out of all of 'em. However, the first Prime was very good, I need to play it again to confirm it on my canon list.

 

[Fr]anc[is]

Once WarCraft introduced the concept of gunpowder in WC3, everything from there and afterward has been "non-canon". It's parallel universe time.

They had gunpowder in WC2 as well. IIRC there were knights in full plate shooting cannons in the opening cutscene. Plus dwarven/goblin sappers.

 

[Ultress]

Any WildArms game after Wild Arms 3 bar WA5 since I haven't played does not exist as far as I'm concerned.

 

[Vault Citizen]

Russell T. Davies era Doctor Who is not Doctor Who. Horrifically written and completely ignorant of Doctor Who's rich mythos.

A shame, since I like Davies Era Who.

Me too, I was kind of annoyed that Davies brought back the time lords only to have them be sent away in the next episode though, I was hoping they were back to stay.

 

[RobfromtheGulag]

Silent Hill Shattered Memories sure as hell isn't cannon.

 

[Something Amyss]

Russell T. Davies era Doctor Who is not Doctor Who. Horrifically written and completely ignorant of Doctor Who's rich mythos.

A shame, since I like Davies Era Who.

Me too, I was kind of annoyed that Davies brought back the time lords only to have them be sent away in the next episode though, I was hoping they were back to stay.

there were two things that pissed me off during Davies' run:

Rose: Not so much to the point here, but she strikes me as her only purpose in most episodes is to fawn over the Doctor and tell us how wonderful he is.

The last of the X: The whole Time Lords being brought back and then killedd off would annoy me more if Davies hadn't brought back the Daleks like 50 times over four series. Cybermen, too. A couple of the Dalek instances weren't so bad, but killing them off every few episodes was SO dumb. there may have been other examples, but the Dalek/Cybermen ones always pop into my head first.

I suppose I could always make a third, in that a lot of the big finishes are asspulls, but
Davies Ex Machina never bothered me as much as "We're back! We're dead! We're back! We're dead! We're back! Emergency Temporal Shift! We're back! We're really dead this time!"

 

[Flames66]

I have declared one episode of the Clone Wars Series to be non-canon. That episode is The Mandalore Plot and it is non-canon because it completely fucked up Mandalore and got everything completely wrong.

 

[EHKOS]

the pokemon games that came after the second one (excluding Fire Red,Leaf Green,Heart Gold and soul silver)

I would punch every person who say's that in the soul if I could because the pokemon games just keep improving in gameplay and pokemon design is only changing in style and is not getting worse or unoriginal.

I'd say a few Gen V pokemon are unoriginal, like the terrier, the pigeon, and Yubukuron. Seriously...a trash bag....

But I as a fan of Pokemon, am willing to overlook that.

 

[emeraldrafael]

The Series of Unfortunate Events: The End (Book 13). The book was fine except I thought the ending felt insubstantial and far to "Happily Ever After" for a book of Unfortunate Events.

The last book was happy?

Not really, just the ending and how they just kinda live peacefully on the island with the baby. Maybe I'm just grim or something, but I expected a much darker ending.

if I remember the book correctly (its been a while since I read it), the thought was they would die on the island, or that the baby wouldnt be raised correctly. That, or they would die at sea.

And besides, we never learned what ahppened to the other allies of the children.

 

[Shraggler]

anc[is]They had gunpowder in WC2 as well. IIRC there were knights in full plate shooting cannons in the opening cutscene. Plus dwarven/goblin sappers.

That's true, but once WC3 went pseudo-steampunk, started going on about "magic addiction" like magic was a finite resource and used the all time cop-out bad guy "the undead", I pretty much left the story at the door.

 

[karloss01]

every sonic game since sonic adventure.

 

[Vault Citizen]

I have declared one episode of the Clone Wars Series to be non-canon. That episode is The Mandalore Plot and it is non-canon because it completely fucked up Mandalore and got everything completely wrong.

I still believe that episode serves a fine purpose in that it rendered the works of Karen Travis non cannon and was the reason why she stopped writing for the Star Wars EU, made an especially good thing by the fact that she was going to write a military guide.

 

[Flames66]

I have declared one episode of the Clone Wars Series to be non-canon. That episode is The Mandalore Plot and it is non-canon because it completely fucked up Mandalore and got everything completely wrong.

I still believe that episode serves a fine purpose in that it rendered the works of Karen Travis non cannon and was the reason why she stopped writing for the Star Wars EU, made an especially good thing by the fact that she was going to write a military guide.

That is exactly the reason I dislike it.

 

[Neverhoodian]

I have declared one episode of the Clone Wars Series to be non-canon. That episode is The Mandalore Plot and it is non-canon because it completely fucked up Mandalore and got everything completely wrong.

I still believe that episode serves a fine purpose in that it rendered the works of Karen Travis non cannon and was the reason why she stopped writing for the Star Wars EU, made an especially good thing by the fact that she was going to write a military guide.

That is exactly the reason I dislike it.

See, this is why I tend to hate Star Wars EU sources with a passion. There is absolutely no quality control or fact checking, resulting in heinous inconsistencies and a complete lack of logic sometimes (the Republic only has three million clones to fight a galaxy-spanning conflict? Don't make me laugh). It only serves to divide the fanbase and confuses the newcomers.

Screw 'em, they're all non-canon in my book (except the X-Wing books, Zahn's Thrawn trilogy, and the Han Solo Adventures).

 

[WorldCritic]

There was never a fourth Indiana Jones.

 

[Vault Citizen]

I have declared one episode of the Clone Wars Series to be non-canon. That episode is The Mandalore Plot and it is non-canon because it completely fucked up Mandalore and got everything completely wrong.

I still believe that episode serves a fine purpose in that it rendered the works of Karen Travis non cannon and was the reason why she stopped writing for the Star Wars EU, made an especially good thing by the fact that she was going to write a military guide.

That is exactly the reason I dislike it.

Why? I've read about what she's introduced (a friend showed me a list) and the stuff on there is just agressively awful.

 

[Disaster Button]

Dragon Ball GT. Yes, I was one of those people who hated it.

Also, Star Trek Enterprise, with the exception of the Mirror Universe episode. Now that episode was awesome and badass, but the rest just doesn't make any sense with the history of Star Trek.

What doesn't make sense is taking the name Star Trek off of it at one point so it would appeal to others. I loved the Dark Mirror episodes though, it showed how good that show could've been.

I did love GT though.